error: type parameter `D` must be used as the type parameter for some local type

Question

I'm using Nickel.rs with MongoDB to build a RESTful api. I'd like to implement a generic Responder for the type mongodb::error::Result<Option<bson::Document>>.

This is the implementation I wrote based on the examples I found for Responder:

impl<D> Responder<D> for Result<Option<Document>> {

    fn respond<'a>(self, mut response: Response<'a, D>) -> MiddlewareResult<'a, D> {
        response.set(MediaType::Json);

        match self {
            Ok(Some(doc))=>{
                ApiResponse{data: Bson::Document(doc).to_json()}.to_json()
            },
            Ok(None)=>{
                response.set(StatusCode::NotFound);
                ApiError{error: "Not found".to_string()}.to_json()
            },
            Err(e)=>{
                response.set(StatusCode::InternalServerError);
                ApiError{error: format!("{}",e)}.to_json()
            }

        }
    }
}

and I'm getting the following error:

error: type parameter D must be used as the type parameter for some local type (e.g. MyStruct<T>); only traits defined in the current crate can be implemented for a type parameter [E0210]

I ran rustc --explain E0210 for an explanation and if my understanding is correct, I need to provide a trait D as a type argument to impl<D>, but I don't understand which trait to provide.

I tried impl<D: =()> but that produced the same error.

Answer 1

When you implement a trait then either the trait or the type you are implementing it for must be defined in the same crate. In you example that is not the case: the trait Responder is defined by nickel, and Result is defined by mongodb.

The common way to work around this is to define your own type, by wrapping the desired type into a tuple struct with a single component (the so-called newtype pattern):

struct Result(mongodb::error::Result<Option<Document>>);

impl Responder for Result {
    ...

Answer 2

Based on starblue's answer, I replaced ApiResponse and ApiError with a tuple struct and refactored my code as follows:

struct ApiResponse<T>(T);

impl<D> Responder<D> for ApiResponse<Result<Option<Document>>> {

    fn respond<'a>(self, mut response: Response<'a, D>) -> MiddlewareResult<'a, D> {

        let mut d = BTreeMap::new();
        match self.0 {
            Ok(Some(doc))=>{
                d.insert("data".to_string(),Bson::Document(doc).to_json());
            },
            Ok(None)=>{
                response.set(StatusCode::NotFound);
                d.insert("error".to_string(),"Not Found".to_json());
            },
            Err(e)=>{
                response.set(StatusCode::InternalServerError);
                d.insert("error".to_string(),format!("{}",e).to_json());
            }

        }
        response.set(MediaType::Json);
        response.send(Json::Object(d))
    }
}