getopt does not parse optional arguments to parameters

Question

In C, getopt_long does not parse the optional arguments to command line parameters parameters.

When I run the program, the optional argument is not recognized like the example run below.

$ ./respond --praise John
Kudos to John
$ ./respond --blame John
You suck !
$ ./respond --blame
You suck !

Here is the test code.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <getopt.h>

int main(int argc, char ** argv )
{
    int getopt_ret, option_index;
    static struct option long_options[] = {
               {"praise",  required_argument, 0, 'p'},
               {"blame",  optional_argument, 0, 'b'},
               {0, 0, 0, 0}       };
    while (1) {
        getopt_ret = getopt_long( argc, argv, "p:b::",
                                  long_options,  &option_index);
        if (getopt_ret == -1) break;

        switch(getopt_ret)
        {
            case 0: break;
            case 'p':
                printf("Kudos to %s\n", optarg); break;
            case 'b':
                printf("You suck ");
                if (optarg)
                    printf (", %s!\n", optarg);
                else
                    printf ("!\n", optarg);
                break;
            case '?':
                printf("Unknown option\n"); break;
        }
    } 
    return 0;
}

Answer 1

Although not mentioned in glibc documentation or getopt man page, optional arguments to long style command line parameters require 'equals sign' (=). Space separating the optional argument from the parameter does not work.

An example run with the test code:

$ ./respond --praise John
Kudos to John
$ ./respond --praise=John
Kudos to John
$ ./respond --blame John
You suck !
$ ./respond --blame=John
You suck , John!

Answer 2

The man page certainly doesn't document it very well, but the source code helps a little.

Briefly: you're supposed to do something like the following (though this may be a little over-pedantic):

if(   !optarg
   && optind < argc // make sure optind is valid
   && NULL != argv[optind] // make sure it's not a null string
   && '\0' != argv[optind][0] // ... or an empty string
   && '-' != argv[optind][0] // ... or another option
  ) {
  // update optind so the next getopt_long invocation skips argv[optind]
  my_optarg = argv[optind++];
}
/* ... */

From among the comments preceding _getopt_internal:

...

If getopt finds another option character, it returns that character, updating optind and nextchar so that the next call to getopt can resume the scan with the following option character or ARGV-element.

If there are no more option characters, getopt returns -1. Then optind is the index in ARGV of the first ARGV-element that is not an option. (The ARGV-elements have been permuted so that those that are not options now come last.) <-- a note from me: if the 3rd argument to getopt_long starts with a dash, argv will not be permuted

...

If a char in OPTSTRING is followed by a colon, that means it wants an arg, so the following text in the same ARGV-element, or the text of the following ARGV-element, is returned in optarg. Two colons mean an option that wants an optional arg; if there is text in the current ARGV-element, it is returned in optarg, otherwise optarg is set to zero.

...

... though you have to do some reading between the lines. The following does what you want:

#include <stdio.h>
#include <getopt.h>

int main(int argc, char* argv[] ) {
  int getopt_ret;
  int option_index;
  static struct option long_options[] = {
      {"praise",  required_argument, 0, 'p'}
    , {"blame",  optional_argument, 0, 'b'}
    , {0, 0, 0, 0}
  };

  while( -1 != ( getopt_ret = getopt_long(  argc
                                          , argv
                                          , "p:b::"
                                          , long_options
                                          , &option_index) ) ) {
    const char *tmp_optarg = optarg;
    switch( getopt_ret ) {
      case 0: break;
      case 1:
        // handle non-option arguments here if you put a `-`
        // at the beginning of getopt_long's 3rd argument
        break;
      case 'p':
        printf("Kudos to %s\n", optarg); break;
      case 'b':
        if(   !optarg
           && NULL != argv[optindex]
           && '-' != argv[optindex][0] ) {
          // This is what makes it work; if `optarg` isn't set
          // and argv[optindex] doesn't look like another option,
          // then assume it's our parameter and overtly modify optindex
          // to compensate.
          //
          // I'm not terribly fond of how this is done in the getopt
          // API, but if you look at the man page it documents the
          // existence of `optarg`, `optindex`, etc, and they're
          // not marked const -- implying they expect and intend you
          // to modify them if needed.
          tmp_optarg = argv[optindex++];
        }
        printf( "You suck" );
        if (tmp_optarg) {
          printf (", %s!\n", tmp_optarg);
        } else {
          printf ("!\n");
        }
        break;
      case '?':
        printf("Unknown option\n");
        break;
      default:
        printf( "Unknown: getopt_ret == %d\n", getopt_ret );
        break;
    }
  }
  return 0;
}

Answer 3

I also ran into the same problem and came here. Then I realised this . You don't have much of a use case of "optional_argument" . If an option is required you check from program logic, if an option is optional then you need not do anything because at getopt level all options are optional , they are not mandatory, so there is no use case of "optional_argument". Hope this helps.

ps: for the above example i think the correct options are --praise --praise-name "name" --blame --blame-name "name"

Answer 4

If you write the argument next to the parameter without space character neither equal also works. For example:

$ ./respond --blameJohn
You suck John!