Precise definition of “functional interface” in Java 8

问题

Recently I started exploring Java 8 and I can\'t quite understand the concept of \"functional interface\" that is essential to Java\'s implementation of lambda expressions. There is a pretty comprehensive guide to lambda functions in Java, but I got stuck on the chapter that gives definition to the concept of functional interfaces. The definition reads:

More precisely, a functional interface is defined as any interface that has exactly one abstract method.

An then he proceeds to examples, one of which is Comparator interface:

public interface Comparator<T> {
    int compare(T o1, T o2);
    boolean equals(Object obj);
} 

I was able to test that I can use a lambda function in place of Comparator argument and it works(i.e. Collections.sort(list, (a, b) -> a-b)).

But in the Comparator interface both compare and equals methods are abstract, which means it has two abstract methods. So how can this be working, if the definition requires an interface to have exactly one abstract method? What am I missing here?

回答1:

From the same page you linked to:

The interface Comparator is functional because although it declares two abstract methods, one of these—equals— has a signature corresponding to a public method in Object. Interfaces always declare abstract methods corresponding to the public methods of Object, but they usually do so implicitly. Whether implicitly or explicitly declared, such methods are excluded from the count.

I can't really say it better.

Edit: Updated to the most recent text of this page, per Maurice's comment (thanks!)

回答2:

Another explanation is given in the @FunctionalInterface page:

Conceptually, a functional interface has exactly one abstract method. Since default methods have an implementation, they are not abstract. If an interface declares an abstract method overriding one of the public methods of java.lang.Object, that also does not count toward the interface's abstract method count since any implementation of the interface will have an implementation from java.lang.Object or elsewhere.

You can test which interface is a correct functional interface using @FunctionalInterface.

E.g.:

• this works

  @FunctionalInterface
  public interface FunctionalInterf {
  
      void m();
  
      boolean equals(Object o);
  
  }
  

• this generates an error:

  @FunctionalInterface
  public interface FunctionalInterf {
  
      void m();
  
      boolean equals();
  
  }
  

  Multiple non-overriding abstract methods found in interface FunctionalInterf

回答3:

Q. But in the Comparator interface both compare() and equals() methods are abstract, which means it has two abstract methods. So how can this be working, if the definition requires an interface to have exactly one abstract method? What am I missing here?

A.

A functional interface may specify any public method defined by Object, such as equals( ), without affecting its “functional interface” status. The public Object methods are considered implicit members of a functional interface because they are automatically implemented by an instance of a functional interface.

回答4:

The Java docs say:

Note that it is always safe not to override Object.equals(Object). However, overriding this method may, in some cases, improve performance by allowing programs to determine that two distinct comparators impose the same order.

Maybe Comparator is special? Maybe, even though it's an interface, there is somehow a default implementation of equals() that calls compare()? Algorithmically, it's trivial.

I thought all methods that were declared in interfaces were abstract (i. e. no default implementation). But maybe I'm missing something.

回答5:

Definition:

If an interface contains only one abstract method, then such type of interface is called functional interface.

Usage:

1. Once we write Lambda expression "->" to invoke its functionality , then in this context we require Functional Interface.
2. We can use the Functional Interface reference to refer Lambda expression.
3. Inside functional interface we can have one abstract method and n number of default/static methods.

Functional interface with respect to inheritance:

If an interface extends Functional interface and the child interface does not contain any abstract method , then the child interface is also considered to be Functional Interface.

Functional interface is not new to java, its already used in following interface API's:

1. Runnable : contains run() method only.
2. Callable : contains call() method only.
3. Comparable : contains compareTo() method only.

回答6:

Before Java 8, an interface could only declare one or more methods also known as Abstract Method (method with no implementation, just the signature). Starting with Java 8 an interface can also have implementation of one or more methods (knows as Interface Default Method) and static methods along with abstract methods. Interface Default Methods are marked default keyword.

So the question is, what is Functional Interface? An interface with Single Abstract Method (SAM) is called Functional Interface.

Which means -

1. An interface with Single Abstract Method is a Functional Interface
2. An interface with Single Abstract Method and zero or more default methods and zero or more static method is also a valid Functional Interface.

More detail with example code https://readtorakesh.blogspot.com/2018/08/functional-interface-java8.html

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/14655913/precise-definition-of-functional-interface-in-java-8