Interpolation (double quoted string) of Associative Arrays in PHP

问题

When interpolating PHP\'s string-indexed array elements (5.3.3, Win32) the following behavior may be expected or not:

$ha = array(\'key1\' => \'Hello to me\');

print $ha[\'key1\'];   # correct (usual way)
print $ha[key1];     # Warning, works (use of undefined constant)

print \"He said {$ha[\'key1\']}\"; # correct (usual way)
print \"He said {$ha[key1]}\";   # Warning, works (use of undefined constant)

print \"He said $ha[\'key1\']\";   # Error, unexpected T_ENCAPSED_AND_WHITESPACE
print \"He said $ha[ key1 ]\";   # Error, unexpected T_ENCAPSED_AND_WHITESPACE
print \"He said $ha[key1]\";     # !! correct (How Comes?)

Inerestingly, the last line seems to be correct PHP code. Any explanations? Can this feature be trusted?

Edit: The point of the posting now set in bold face in order to reduce misunderstandings.

回答1:

Yes, you may trust it. All ways of interpolation a variable are covered in the documentation pretty well.

If you want to have a reason why this was done so, well, I can't help you there. But as always: PHP is old and has evolved a lot, thus introducing inconsistent syntax.

回答2:

Yes, this is well defined behavior, and will always look for the string key 'key', and not the value of the (potentially undefined) constant key.

For example, consider the following code:

$arr = array('key' => 'val');
define('key', 'defined constant');
echo "\$arr[key] within string is: $arr[key]";

This will output the following:

$arr[key] within string is: val

That said, it's probably not best practice to write code like this, and instead either use:

$string = "foo {$arr['key']}"

$string = 'foo ' . $arr['key']

syntax.

回答3:

The last one is a special case handled by the PHP tokenizer. It does not look up if any constant by that name was defined, it always assumes a string literal for compatibility with PHP3 and PHP4.

回答4:

To answer your question, yes, yes it can, and much like implode and explode, php is very very forgiving... so inconsistency abound

And I have to say I like PHP's interpolation for basical daisy punching variables into strings then and there,

However if your doing only string variable interpolation using a single array's objects, it may be easier to write a template which you can daisy print a specific object variables into (like in say javascript or python) and hence explicit control over the variable scope and object being applied to the string

I though this guy's isprintf really useful for this kind of thing

http://www.frenck.nl/2013/06/string-interpolation-in-php.html

<?php

$values = array(
    'who'   => 'me honey and me',
    'where' => 'Underneath the mango tree',
    'what'  => 'moon',
);

echo isprintf('%(where)s, %(who)s can watch for the %(what)s', $values);

// Outputs: Underneath the mango tree, me honey and me can watch for the moon

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4738850/interpolation-double-quoted-string-of-associative-arrays-in-php

标签

php

associative-array