What's the best practice to define an abstract instance attribute, but not as a property?
I would like to write something like:
class AbstractFoo(metaclass=ABCMeta):
@property
@abstractmethod
def bar(self):
pass
class Foo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
self.bar = 3
Instead of:
class Foo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
self._bar = 3
@property
def bar(self):
return self._bar
@bar.setter
def setbar(self, bar):
self._bar = bar
@bar.deleter
def delbar(self):
del self._bar
Properties are handy, but for simple attribute requiring no computation they are an overkill. This is especially important for abstract classes which will be subclassed and implemented by the user (I don't want to force someone to use @property when he just could have written self.foo = foo in the __init__).
Abstract attributes in Python question proposes as only answer to use @property and @abstractmethod: it doesn't answer my question.
The ActiveState recipe for an abstract class attribute via AbstractAttribute may be the right way, but I am not sure. It also only works with class attributes and not instance attributes.
If you really want to enforce that a subclass define a given attribute, you can use metaclass. Personally, I think it may be overkill and not very pythonic, but you could do something like this:
class AbstractFooMeta(type):
def __call__(cls, *args, **kwargs):
"""Called when you call Foo(*args, **kwargs) """
obj = type.__call__(cls, *args, **kwargs)
obj.check_bar()
return obj
class AbstractFoo(object):
__metaclass__ = AbstractFooMeta
bar = None
def check_bar(self):
if self.bar is None:
raise NotImplementedError('Subclasses must define bar')
class GoodFoo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
self.bar = 3
class BadFoo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
pass
Basically the meta class redefine __call__ to make sure check_bar is called after the init on an instance.
GoodFoo() # ok
BadFoo () # yield NotImplementedError
It's 2018, we deserve a bit better solution:
from better_abc import ABCMeta, abstract_attribute # see below
class AbstractFoo(metaclass=ABCMeta):
@abstract_attribute
def bar(self):
pass
class Foo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
self.bar = 3
class BadFoo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
pass
It will behave like this:
Foo() # ok
BadFoo() # will raise: NotImplementedError: Can't instantiate abstract class BadFoo
# with abstract attributes: bar
This answer uses same approach as the accepted answer, but integrates well with built-in ABC and does not require boilerplate of check_bar() helpers.
Here is the better_abc.py content:
from abc import ABCMeta as NativeABCMeta
class DummyAttribute:
pass
def abstract_attribute(obj=None):
if obj is None:
obj = DummyAttribute()
obj.__is_abstract_attribute__ = True
return obj
class ABCMeta(NativeABCMeta):
def __call__(cls, *args, **kwargs):
instance = NativeABCMeta.__call__(cls, *args, **kwargs)
abstract_attributes = {
name
for name in dir(instance)
if getattr(getattr(instance, name), '__is_abstract_attribute__', False)
}
if abstract_attributes:
raise NotImplementedError(
"Can't instantiate abstract class {} with"
" abstract attributes: {}".format(
cls.__name__,
', '.join(abstract_attributes)
)
)
return instance
The nice thing is that you can do:
class AbstractFoo(metaclass=ABCMeta):
bar = abstract_attribute()
and it will work same as above.
Also one can use:
class ABC(ABCMeta):
pass
to define custom ABC helper. PS. I consider this code to be CC0.
This could be improved by using AST parser to raise earlier (on class declaration) by scanning the __init__ code, but it seems to be an overkill for now (unless someone is willing to implement).
Just because you define it as an abstractproperty on the abstract base class doesn't mean you have to make a property on the subclass.
e.g. you can:
In [1]: from abc import ABCMeta, abstractproperty
In [2]: class X(metaclass=ABCMeta):
...: @abstractproperty
...: def required(self):
...: raise NotImplementedError
...:
In [3]: class Y(X):
...: required = True
...:
In [4]: Y()
Out[4]: <__main__.Y at 0x10ae0d390>
If you want to initialise the value in __init__ you can do this:
In [5]: class Z(X):
...: required = None
...: def __init__(self, value):
...: self.required = value
...:
In [6]: Z(value=3)
Out[6]: <__main__.Z at 0x10ae15a20>
The problem isn't what, but when:
from abc import ABCMeta, abstractmethod
class AbstractFoo(metaclass=ABCMeta):
@abstractmethod
def bar():
pass
class Foo(AbstractFoo):
bar = object()
isinstance(Foo(), AbstractFoo)
#>>> True
It doesn't matter that bar isn't a method! The problem is that __subclasshook__, the method of doing the check, is a classmethod, so only cares whether the class, not the instance, has the attribute.
I suggest you just don't force this, as it's a hard problem. The alternative is forcing them to predefine the attribute, but that just leaves around dummy attributes that just silence errors.
I've searched around for this for awhile but didn't see anything I like. As you probably know if you do:
class AbstractFoo(object):
@property
def bar(self):
raise NotImplementedError(
"Subclasses of AbstractFoo must set an instance attribute "
"self._bar in it's __init__ method")
class Foo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
self.bar = "bar"
f = Foo()
You get an AttributeError: can't set attribute which is annoying.
To get around this you can do:
class AbstractFoo(object):
@property
def bar(self):
try:
return self._bar
except AttributeError:
raise NotImplementedError(
"Subclasses of AbstractFoo must set an instance attribute "
"self._bar in it's __init__ method")
class OkFoo(AbstractFoo):
def __init__(self):
self._bar = 3
class BadFoo(AbstractFoo):
pass
a = OkFoo()
b = BadFoo()
print a.bar
print b.bar # raises a NotImplementedError
This avoids the AttributeError: can't set attribute but if you just leave off the abstract property all together:
class AbstractFoo(object):
pass
class Foo(AbstractFoo):
pass
f = Foo()
f.bar
You get an AttributeError: 'Foo' object has no attribute 'bar' which is arguably almost as good as the NotImplementedError. So really my solution is just trading one error message from another .. and you have to use self._bar rather than self.bar in the init.
Following https://docs.python.org/2/library/abc.html you could do something like this in Python 2.7:
from abc import ABCMeta, abstractproperty
class Test(object):
__metaclass__ = ABCMeta
@abstractproperty
def test(self): yield None
def get_test(self):
return self.test
class TestChild(Test):
test = None
def __init__(self, var):
self.test = var
a = TestChild('test')
print(a.get_test())
来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/23831510/abstract-attribute-not-property