A way to convert byte stream to packet stream in C89 on an embedded device [closed]

问题

As it currently stands, this question is not a good fit for our Q&A format. We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion. If you feel that this question can be improved and possibly reopened, visit the help center for guidance.

Closed 6 years ago.

I’m working on with an embedded device that is connected to PC using rs232 (rs232 over USB).

I’m thinking about developing my own protocol:

<MAGIC><LENGTH><BINARY DATA><CRC>

but I don’t want to reinvent the wheel.

Please note that: I'm thinking about quite restricted device: 4kb of RAM, no kernel, nor standard C lib.

Can you think about a standard way to do this (maybe open source library)?

If you code your own solution do have any best practices?

• Do you use MAGIC bytes also at the end of packages?
• Maybe it is better to use time gaps instead of delimiters?
• How do you find the beginning of packages in a stream binary data?
• Maybe it is better to use text protocols?

UPDATE: Please re read the question. I shouldn't ask for library but for good practices.

回答1:

See this answer I gave to a very similar question regarding details of a simple protocol.

To respond to your specific points:

1. "Magic" bytes at the end of packets don't do any harm, but they're redundant if you already know how long the packet is supposed to be, and have a CRC.
2. It can be sensible to specifiy timeout times, so if there's too big a gap between bytes within one packet, then an error is flagged. Having used Modbus, I'm not convinced of the value of using time-based delimiters elsewhere.
3. Do you mean, "how do you find the beginning of packets in a stream of binary data"? If so, maybe specify a minimum gap between packets, and/or require the recipient to acknolwedge after every packet.
4. Makes it easier for debugging, and doesn't require any special software on the PC, but not very efficient. Of course, if usability is more important than efficiency, than a text-based system is entirely appropriate.

回答2:

For something like this by the time you get an existing solution to work on your device, it would have been easier just to reinvent the wheel.

void buffer_packet(unsigned char rx_byte)
{
    static unsigned char byte_count = 0;
    static unsigned char packet[8];

    packet[byte_count++] = rx_byte;
    if (byte_count == 8)
    {
        unsigned char crc = calculate_crc(packet, 8);

        write_uart(0x55);
        write_uart(8);
        while (byte_count--)
        {
            write_uart(packet[7 - byte_count]);
        }
        write_uart(crc);
    }
}

Or maybe I am underestimating your problem. If you're looking for how to generate the RS232 bits look in your microcontrollers datasheet.

回答3:

About the only thing there beyond your I/O primitives is going to be the CRC calculation. There's a nifty article, with code, here.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/815029/a-way-to-convert-byte-stream-to-packet-stream-in-c89-on-an-embedded-device