Is Unitils project alive?

社会主义新天地 提交于 2019-11-29 08:31:47

Unitils seems to be almost abandoned nowadays. Project is available on the GitHub here and you can look at its history and activity.

Anyways my two cents...

Unitils has serious drawbacks:

  • Integrates many third-party libs (easymock, dbunit, spring, dbmaintainer, xmlunit, slf4j etc) and thus forces their versions - it is a really serious drawback
  • Due to being dependent on many 3rd party libraries, it is almost impossible to keep it up to date without any company behind.
  • Unitils 4.0 is developed since 06.2011 and was planned to release at 01.2012, but now (01.2016) after 4 years is still not released.

DbUnit

For database-driven apps it may seem that interesting way to go is a plain DbUnit + Spring-Test or alternatively some 3rd party tools:

  • excilys/spring-dbunit that comes with handy @DataSet annotation and is actively developed on the github, also is constantly updated to use the newest versions of DbUnit and Spring Framework.
  • springtestdbunit/spring-test-dbunit which is also hosted on the github (comes with a @DatabaseSetup annotation).

Both are very similar, but personally I find DbUnit confusing, quite cumbersome and time-consuming. Why? Try to maintain large amount of small xml files and you find out what I mean. Also combining multiple data sets is really hard.

DbSetup

My choice. DbSetup doesn't need external xml/ json files, is extremely convenient and allows you to combine freely multiple data sets using fluent builders. Just look at code below:

 final Operation sql =
         sequenceOf(
                 CommonOperations.DELETE_ALL,
                 CommonOperations.INSERT_REFERENCE_DATA,
                 prepareSpecialData()
         );
 DbSetup dbSetup = new DbSetup(new DataSourceDestination(dataSource), sql);

Everything is java, so you can freely refactor it, extract methods etc.

Hope it helps.

易学教程内所有资源均来自网络或用户发布的内容,如有违反法律规定的内容欢迎反馈
该文章没有解决你所遇到的问题?点击提问,说说你的问题,让更多的人一起探讨吧!