Is there a way to exclude NULL values from Azure Cognitive Search Indexes

心不动则不痛 提交于 2021-02-05 08:44:30

问题


So for example we have field 1 up to 10. I want to index all the field in Azure Search, so you can filter, search on those filters.

My Question is, is there a way to just exclude the fields that are NULL from a specific ID, so not store them in Azure search? See example underneath.

The data itself is initially stored in Azure Cosmos Database. In Azure Cosmos DB it would like this:

  • Id 1
  • field 1: a
  • field 2: b
  • field 5: c
  • field 6: d
  • field 8: e


  • Id 2
  • field 3: a
  • field 2: b
  • field 5: c
  • field 9: d
  • field 10: e

However in Azure Search Index, it looks like this:

  • Id 1
  • field 1:a
  • field 2:b
  • field 3:NULL
  • field 4:NULL
  • field 5:c
  • field 6:d
  • field 7:NULL
  • field 8:e
  • field 9:NULL
  • field 10:NULL


  • Id 2
  • field 1:NULL
  • field 2:b
  • field 3:a
  • field 4:NULL
  • field 5:c
  • field 6:NULL
  • field 7:NULL
  • field 8:NULL
  • field 9:d
  • field 10:e

回答1:


The shortest answer to your question is "no", but it's a little deeper than that.

When you add documents to an Azure Cognitive Search index, the values of each field are stored in a data structure called an inverted index. This stores a dictionary of terms found in the field, and each entry contains a list of document IDs containing that term. It is somewhat similar to a column-oriented database in that regard. The null value that you see in document JSON is never actually stored in the inverted index. This can make it expensive to test whether a field is null, since the query needs to look for all document IDs not contained in the inverted index, but it is perfectly efficient in terms of storage (because it doesn't consume any).

This article has a few simplified examples of how inverted indexes work, although it's about a different topic than your question.

Your broader concern about having many fields defined in your index is a valid one. There is a tradeoff between schema flexibility and resource utilization as you increase the number of fields in your index. However, this is due to the bookkeeping overhead required for each field, not the "number of nulls in the field" (which doesn't really mean anything since nulls aren't stored).

From your question, it sounds like you're trying to model different "entity types" in the same index, resulting in a sparse index where some subset of the documents have one subset of fields defined, while another subset of documents have different fields defined. This is a scenario that we want to better support in the service. One promising future direction could be supporting multi-index query, so each subset of your schema could have its own index with its own distinct (but perhaps overlapping) set of fields. This is not on our immediate roadmap, but it's something we want to investigate further. Please vote on this User Voice item to help us prioritize.




回答2:


As far as not saving the null values, AFAIK it is not possible. An index in Cognitive Search has a pre-defined schema (much like a relational database table) and based on an attribute's data type an attribute's value will be initialized with a default value (null for most of the data types).




回答3:


If your concern is storage, it's not a problem since it's an inverted index.

If you have an issue with the complexity of the JSON data returned, you could implement your own intermediate service that just hides all NULL values from the JSON. So, your application queries your own query service which in turn queries the actual Azure service. Just passing along all parameters as-is. The only difference is that your service removes both the key/value from the JSON to make the responses easier to manage.

The response from search would then appear to be identical to your Cosmos record.



来源:https://stackoverflow.com/questions/62695523/is-there-a-way-to-exclude-null-values-from-azure-cognitive-search-indexes

易学教程内所有资源均来自网络或用户发布的内容,如有违反法律规定的内容欢迎反馈
该文章没有解决你所遇到的问题?点击提问,说说你的问题,让更多的人一起探讨吧!