about race condition of weak_ptr

问题

1. i posted the question(About thread-safety of weak_ptr) several days ago,and I have the other related question now. If i do something like this,will introduce a race condition as g_w in above example ?(my platform is ms vs2013)

std::weak_ptr<int> g_w;

void f3()
{
    std::shared_ptr<int>l_s3 = g_w.lock(); //2. here will read g_w
    if (l_s3)
    {
        ;/.....
    }
}

void f4() //f4 run in main thread
{
    std::shared_ptr<int> p_s = std::make_shared<int>(1);
    g_w = p_s;

    std::thread th(f3); // f3 run in the other thread
    th.detach();
    // 1. p_s destory will motify g_w (write g_w)
}

2.As i know std::shared_ptr/weak_ptr derived from std::tr1::shared_ptr/weak_ptr, and std::tr1::shared_ptr/weak_ptr derived from boost::shared_ptr/weak_ptr, are there any difference on the implement,especially, in the relief of thread-safe.

回答1:

The completed construction of a std::thread synchronizes with the invocation of the specified function in the thread being created, i.e., everything that happens in f4 before the construction of std::thread th is guaranteed to be visible to the new thread when it starts executing f3. In particular the write to g_w in f4 (g_w = p_s;) will be visible to the new thread in f4.

The statement in your comment // 1. p_s destory will motify g_w (write g_w) is incorrect. Destruction of p_s does not access g_w in any way. In most implementations it does modify a common control block that's used to track all shared and weak references to the pointee. Any such modifications to objects internal to the standard library implementation are the library's problem to make threadsafe, not yours, per C++11 § 17.6.5.9/7 "Implementations may share their own internal objects between threads if the objects are not visible to users and are protected against data races."

Assuming no concurrent modifications to g_w somewhere else in the program, and no other threads executing f3, there is no data race in this program on g_w.

回答2:

@Casey

Firstly, I complete my code.

int main()
{
  f4();
  getchar();
  retrun 0;
}

And I find some code in my visual studio 2013.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/20754370/about-race-condition-of-weak-ptr

标签

multithreading

c++11

race-condition

weak-ptr