Is there a more efficient way to calculate the power set of an array?

问题

This is my current implementation using bits:

Function Array_PowerSet(Self)
    Array_PowerSet = Array()
    PowerSetUpperBound = -1
    For Combination = 1 To 2 ^ (UBound(Self) - LBound(Self)) ' I don't want the null set
        Subset = Array()
        SubsetUpperBound = -1
        For NthBit = 0 To Int(WorksheetFunction.Log(Combination, 2))
            If Combination And 2 ^ NthBit Then
                SubsetUpperBound = SubsetUpperBound + 1
                ReDim Preserve Self(0 To SubsetUpperBound)
                Subset(SubsetUpperBound) = Self(NthBit)
            End If
        Next
        PowerSetUpperBound = PowerSetUpperBound + 1
        ReDim Preserve Array_PowerSet(0 To PowerSetUpperBound)
        Array_PowerSet(PowerSetUpperBound) = Subset
    Next
End Function

Please ignore the abuse of Variants. Array_Push and Array_Size should be self-explanatory.

Previously, I was generating a binary string for each combination, but that involved calling another function which wasn't very efficient.

Aside from using less Variants and moving external function calls inside, is there any way I can make this more efficient?

EDIT: Here's a fully independent version.

Function Array_PowerSet(Self As Variant) As Variant
    Dim PowerSet() As Variant, PowerSetIndex As Long, Size As Long, Combination As Long, NthBit As Long
    PowerSetIndex = -1: Size = UBound(Self) - LBound(Self) + 1
    ReDim PowerSet(0 To 2 ^ Size - 2) ' Don't want null set

    For Combination = 1 To 2 ^ Size - 1
        Dim Subset() As Variant, SubsetIndex As Long: SubsetIndex = -1

        For NthBit = 0 To Int(WorksheetFunction.Log(Combination, 2))
            If Combination And 2 ^ NthBit Then
                SubsetIndex = SubsetIndex + 1
                ReDim Preserve Subset(0 To SubsetIndex)
                Subset(SubsetIndex) = Self(NthBit)
            End If
        Next

        PowerSetIndex = PowerSetIndex + 1
        PowerSet(PowerSetIndex) = Subset
    Next

    Array_PowerSet = PowerSet
End Function

And a test:

Dim Input_() As Variant, Output_() As Variant, Subset As Variant, Value As Variant
Input_ = Array(1, 2, 3)
Output_ = Array_PowerSet(Input_)

For Each Subset In Output_
    Dim StringRep As String: StringRep = "{"

    For Each Value In Subset
        StringRep = StringRep & Value & ", "
    Next

    Debug.Print Left$(StringRep, Len(StringRep) - 2) & "}"
Next

回答1:

Since the number of subsets grows exponentially, no algorithm is truly efficient, although there is room for improvement in what you are doing:

ReDim Preserve, when used to extend an array by a single item, is inefficient since it involves creating a new array with 1 more space and then copying the old elements to the new array. It is better to pre-allocate enough space and then trim it down to size:

Function PowerSet(Items As Variant) As Variant
    'assumes that Items is a 0-based array
    'returns a 0-based jagged array of subsets of Items
    'where each subset is a 0-based array

    Dim PS As Variant
    Dim i As Long, j As Long, k As Long, n As Long
    Dim subset As Variant

    n = 1 + UBound(Items) 'cardinality of the base set
    ReDim PS(0 To 2 ^ n - 2)
    For i = 1 To 2 ^ n - 1
        subset = Array()
        ReDim subset(0 To n - 1)
        k = -1 'will be highest used index of the subset
        For j = 0 To n - 1
            If i And 2 ^ j Then
                k = k + 1
                subset(k) = Items(j)
            End If
        Next j
        ReDim Preserve subset(0 To k)
        PS(i - 1) = subset
    Next i
    PowerSet = PS
End Function

A test function:

Sub test()
    Dim stuff As Variant, subsets As Variant
    Dim i As Long

    stuff = Array("a", "b", "c", "d")
    subsets = PowerSet(stuff)
    For i = LBound(subsets) To UBound(subsets)
        Cells(i + 1, 1).Value = "{" & Join(subsets(i), ",") & "}"
    Next i
End Sub

回答2:

Using collections to build your sets is an option...

Function Generator()
    Dim Arr() As Variant: Arr = Array(1, 2, 3, 4)
    Dim PSCol As Collection: Set PSCol = PowerSetCol(Arr)
    Dim SubSet As Collection, SubSetStr As String

    For i = 1 To PSCol.Count
        Set SubSet = PSCol.Item(i)
        SubSetStr = "{"
        For j = 1 To SubSet.Count
            SubSetStr = SubSetStr & SubSet.Item(j) & IIf(j = SubSet.Count, "", ", ")
        Next j
        SubSetStr = SubSetStr & "}"
        Debug.Print SubSetStr
    Next i
End Function

Function PowerSetCol(Arr As Variant) As Collection

    Dim n As Long, i As Long
    Dim Temp As New Collection, SubSet As Collection

    For i = 1 To 2 ^ (UBound(Arr) + 1) - 1
        Set SubSet = New Collection
        For n = 0 To UBound(Arr)
            If i And 2 ^ n Then SubSet.Add Arr(n)
        Next n
        Temp.Add SubSet
    Next i
    Set PowerSetCol = Temp
End Function

******* EDIT ********

Apparently accessing collections through index is more intensive than enumerating through the items. Also; you can't use join directly as stated by @John Coleman but a single line function can be used in it's place.

Hopefully the code below is a more optimal solution

Function Generator()
    Dim Arr() As Variant: Arr = Array(1, 2, 3, 4)
    Dim PSColl As Collection: Set PSColl = PowerSetColl(Arr)

    Dim Str As String, Coll As Collection, Item As Variant
    For Each Coll In PSColl
        Str = ""
        For Each Item In Coll
            Str = strJoin(", ", Str, CStr(Item))
        Next Item
        Debug.Print "{" & Str & "}"
    Next Coll
End Function

Function PowerSetColl(Arr As Variant) As Collection
    Dim Temp As New Collection, SubSet As Collection
    Dim n As Long, i As Long

    For i = 1 To 2 ^ (UBound(Arr) + 1) - 1
        Set SubSet = New Collection
        For n = 0 To UBound(Arr)
            If i And 2 ^ n Then SubSet.Add Arr(n)
        Next n
        Temp.Add SubSet
    Next i
    Set PowerSetColl = Temp
End Function

Function strJoin(Delimiter As String, Optional Str1 As String, Optional Str2 As String) As String
    strJoin = IIf(IsMissing(Str1) Or Str1 = "", Str2, IIf(IsMissing(Str2) Or Str2 = "", Str1, Str1 & Delimiter & Str2))
End Function

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/45084496/is-there-a-more-efficient-way-to-calculate-the-power-set-of-an-array