How to cleanly interrupt a thread blocking on a recv call?

问题

I have a multithreaded server written in C, with each client thread looking something like this:

ssize_t n;
struct request request;

// Main loop: receive requests from the client and send responses.
while(running && (n = recv(sockfd, &request, sizeof(request), 0)) == sizeof(request)) {
    // Process request and send response.
}
if(n == -1)
    perror("Error receiving request from client");
else if(n != sizeof(act))
    fprintf(stderr, "Error receiving request from client: Incomplete data\n");

// Clean-up code.

At some point, a client meets a certain criteria where it must be disconnected. If the client is regularly sending requests, this is fine because it can be informed of the disconnection in the responses; However sometimes the clients take a long time to send a request, so the client threads end up blocking in the recv call, and the client does not get disconnected until the next request/response.

Is there a clean way to disconnect the client from another thread while the client thread is blocking in the recv call? I tried close(sockfd) but that causes the error Error receiving request from client: Bad file descriptor to occur, which really isn't accurate.

Alternatively, is there a better way for me to be handling errors here?

回答1:

So you have at least these possibilities:

(1) pthread_kill will blow the thread out of recv with errno == EINTR and you can clean up and exit the thread on your own. Some people think this is nasty. Depends, really.

(2) Make your client socket(s) non-blocking and use select to wait on input for a specific period of time before checking if a switch used between the threads has been set to indicated they should shut down.

(3) In combo with (2) have each thread share a pipe with the master thread. Add it to the select. If it becomes readable and contains a shutdonw request, the thread shuts itself down.

(4) Look into the pthread_cancel mechanism if none of the above (or variations thereof) do not meet your needs.

回答2:

Shutdown the socket for input from another thread. That will cause the reading thread to receive an EOS, which should cause it to close the socket and terminate if it is correctly written.

回答3:

To interrupt the thread, make the socket non-blocking (set O_NONBLOCK using fcntl) and then signal the thread with pthread_kill. This way, recv will fail with either EINTR if it was sleeping, or EAGAIN or EWOULDBLOCK if it wasn’t (also maybe if SA_RESTART is in effect, didn’t check). Note that the socket doesn’t need to, and actually should not, be non-blocking before that. (And of course the signal needs to be handled; empty handler is sufficient).

To be sure to catch the stop-signal but not anything else, use a flag; there are things that may go wrong. For example, recv may fail with EINTR on some spurious signal. Or it may succeed if there was some data available, effectively ignoring the stop request.

And what not to do:

1. Don’t use pthread_kill alone or with any plain check. It may arrive right before issuing the recv syscall, too early to interrupt it but after all the checks.

2. Don’t close the socket. That may not even work, and as @R.. pointer out, is dangerous as the socket file descriptor may be reused between close and recv (unless you’re sure nothing opens file descriptors).

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/17822025/how-to-cleanly-interrupt-a-thread-blocking-on-a-recv-call