Utility of macros for enum

问题

One header socket.h on my Linux system looks like the following.

/* Bits in the FLAGS argument to `send', `recv', et al.  */
enum
  {
    MSG_OOB             = 0x01, /* Process out-of-band data.  */
#define MSG_OOB         MSG_OOB
    MSG_PEEK            = 0x02, /* Peek at incoming messages.  */
#define MSG_PEEK        MSG_PEEK
    MSG_DONTROUTE       = 0x04, /* Don't use local routing.  */
#define MSG_DONTROUTE   MSG_DONTROUTE
...

Defining an enum is sort of an idiom for creating type-safe-ish constants in C that the language actually treats as compile-time constants.

My question is : what purpose does the definition of macros MSG_OOB, MSG_PEEK, … that expand to themselves serve?

回答1:

The POSIX standard mandates that "symbolic constants" such as MSG_DONTROUTE be "object-like macros", rather than enumerants. Defining them to themselves allows them to be used in the context of the enumeration, as well as working properly with, e.g., #ifdef.

From the POSIX standard:

The header shall define the following symbolic constants .... MSG_DONTROUTE

And:

symbolic constant... refers to a C preprocessor symbol (also without arguments).

And finally, from an appendix:

Where a constant is required to be a macro but is also allowed to be another type of constant such as an enumeration constant, on implementations which do define it as another type of constant the macro is typically defined as follows:

#define macro_name macro_name

This allows applications to use #ifdef, etc. to determine whether the macro is defined, but the macro is not usable in #if preprocessor directives because the preprocessor will treat the unexpanded word macro_name as having the value zero.

回答2:

The purpose of these defines is that the application can do something like

#ifdef MSG_OOB
  some code here
#endif

expansion of macros is not recursive so the evaluation of macro MSG_OOB results in the enum constant MSG_OOB of the same name.

To also have the constants declared as enum helps for example when you are debugging.

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/21855326/utility-of-macros-for-enum

标签

c-preprocessor