How to use OFFSET and Fetch without Order by in SQL Server

Question

I want use OFFSET and Fetch in my SQL server 2012 query.But without any order by.I can not use order by.Because my sort order will be lost. How can I use OFFSET and Fetch without order by and row number and where in my query? My 2 select tables have same structure.

INSERT INTO @TempTable [some columns]  
select [some columns] from table1 order by col1 
INSERT INTO @TempTable [same columns]
select [some columns] from table2 order by col2
select * from @TempTable OFFSET 20 ROWS FETCH NEXT 50 ROWS ONLY

This query has syntax error at OFFSET keyword.

Answer 1

By adding an identity column to the temp table variable

    declare @TempTable table([some columns], rownr int identity(1,1) )

    INSERT INTO @TempTable [some columns]  
    select [some columns] from table1  order by col1 

    INSERT INTO @TempTable [same columns]
    select [some columns] from table2 order by col2

An automatic incrementing number is added for each row, in the order in which they are added to the temp table. The inserts don't need to fill this column, so the inserts can remain as they are. The identity column can then be used for the order by:

 select * from @TempTable Order by rownr OFFSET 20 ROWS FETCH NEXT 50 ROWS ONLY

Answer 2

There is an even simpler way of providing a dummy ORDER BY clause:

select * from @TempTable ORDER BY(SELECT NULL) OFFSET 20 ROWS FETCH NEXT 50 ROWS ONLY

Answer 3

You cannot avoid using the required syntax of a ORDER BY with OFFSET and FETCH.

It is however possible to disassociate the ORDER BY clause that you must provide in order to perform paging from the natural table order created by the record insert process.

Using the solution below you do not have to make any changes to the underlying table either

Select 0 as TempSort, T.* From MyTable T ORDER BY TempSort OFFSET 2 ROWS FETCH NEXT 3 ROWS

Answer 4

After research and according to comments, The clear and summary answer is : "There is no way!"

But you can remain your sort order with row_number(). So I provided a new tested query that remain the sort order of temp table(final table) with OFFSET and FETCH clause.

    INSERT INTO @TempTable [some columns]  
    select [some columns],row_number() OVER (order by col1) row from table1 order by col1 

    declare @maxrow int
    select @maxrow=max(rn) from @TempTable

    INSERT INTO @TempTable [same columns]
    select [some columns],((row_number() OVER (order by col2)) + @maxrow) row from table2 order by col2

    select * from @TempTable Order by row  OFFSET 20 ROWS FETCH NEXT 50 ROWS ONLY

Answer 5

Offset/Fetch requires an order by clause. You can use the CURRENT_TIMESTAMP to bypass this requirement if you don't want to go by any order. I am not sure but, this should return rows based on the order of storage (clustered index maybe)

So changing your code to this should solve the issue -

INSERT INTO @TempTable [some columns]  
select [some columns] from table1 order by col1 
INSERT INTO @TempTable [same columns]
select [some columns] from table2 order by col2
select * from @TempTable **order by current_timestamp** OFFSET 20 ROWS FETCH NEXT 50 ROWS ONLY