Most appropriate place for bounds checking - constructor or setter?

问题

Still relatively new to Java and I'm wondering which is the better way to handle this. I have a class constructor that takes a few parameters, and also in this class are public getters and setters:

private String name;
private Float value;

public MySampleClass(String theName, Float theValue) {
    setName(theName);
    setValue(theValue);
}

public void setName(String n) {
    this.name = n;
}

public value setValue(Float v) {
    this.value = v;
}

I'd like to do some bounds checking on this Float. It seems like the best place to put it would be in the setter:

public value setValue(Float v) {
    if (v < 0.0f) {
        this.value = 0.0f;
    } else if (v > 1.0f) {
        this.value = 1.0f;
    }
}

This code originally had the bounds checking in the constructor and again in the setter, which seemed redundant. I changed the constructor to call the setter and put the checks in there. Does that make more sense? Or am I violating some convention of which I am completely unaware?

回答1:

Calling overridable methods from your constructor is a bad idea. Do something more like this:

private String name;
private Float value;

public MySampleClass(String theName, Float theValue) {
    this.name = theName;
    setValueImpl(theValue);
}

public void setName(String n) {
    this.name = n;
}

public void setValue(Float v) {
    setValueImpl(v);
}

private void setValueImpl(Float v) {
    if (v < 0.0f) {
        this.value = 0.0f;
    } else if (v > 1.0f) {
        this.value = 1.0f;
    }
}

This gives you the validation in both places and eliminates the calls to overridable methods. See this question for more on this.

Edit: If you plan on subclassing MySampleClass and want the validation setter available, declare it protected final instead of private.

回答2:

For fairly simple data checks, such as your example, then yes, it makes the most sense to do the validation in the setter. However, if the validation for theValue also depends on theName (or on other things), then it would probably be worthwhile to perform the validation in the constructor (or on a private method that the constructor calls).

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/12410338/most-appropriate-place-for-bounds-checking-constructor-or-setter

标签

java

coding-style

constructor

getter-setter