ContentProvider insert() always runs on UI thread?

Question

I have an app that needs to pull data from a server and insert it into an SQLite database in response to user input. I thought this would be pretty simple - the code that pulls the data from the server is a fairly straightforward subclass of AsyncTask, and it works exactly as I expect it to without hanging the UI thread. I implemented callback functionality for it with a simple interface and wrapped it in a static class, so my code looks like this:

MyServerCaller.getFolderContents(folderId, new OnFolderContentsResponseListener() {
    @Override
    public void onFolderContentsResponse(final List<FilesystemEntry> contents) {
        // do something with contents
    }
}

All still good. Even if the server takes an hour to retrieve the data, the UI still runs smoothly, because the code in getFolderContents is running in the doInBackground method of an AsyncTask (which is in a separate thread from the UI). At the very end of the getFolderContents method, the onFolderContentsResponse is called and passed the list of FilesystemEntry's that was received from the server. I only really say all this so that it's hopefully clear that my problem is not in the getFolderContents method or in any of my networking code, because it doesn't ever occur there.

The problem arises when I try to insert into a database via my subclass of ContentProvider within the onFolderContentsResponse method; the UI always hangs while that code is executing, leading me to believe that despite being called from the doInBackground method of an AsyncTask, the inserts are somehow still running on the UI thread. Here's what the problematic code looks like:

MyServerCaller.getFolderContents(folderId, new OnFolderContentsResponseListener() {
    @Override
    public void onFolderContentsResponse(final List<FilesystemEntry> contents) {
        insertContentsIntoDB(contents);
    }
}

And the insertContentsIntoDB method:

void insertContentsIntoDB(final List<FilesystemEntry> contents) {
    for (FilesystemEntry entry : contents) {
        ContentValues values = new ContentValues();
        values.put(COLUMN_1, entry.attr1);
        values.put(COLUMN_2, entry.attr2);
        // etc.

        mContentResolver.insert(MyContentProvider.CONTENT_URI, values);
    }
}

where mContentResolver has been previously set to the result of the getContentResolver() method.

I've tried putting insertContentsIntoDB in its own Thread, like so:

MyServerCaller.getFolderContents(folderId, new OnFolderContentsResponseListener() {
    @Override
    public void onFolderContentsResponse(final List<FilesystemEntry> contents) {
        new Thread(new Runnable() {
            @Override
            public void run() {
                insertContentsIntoDB(contents);
            }
        }).run();
    }
}

I've also tried running each individual insert in its own thread (the insert method in MyContentProvider is synchronized, so this shouldn't cause any issues there):

void insertContentsIntoDB(final List<FilesystemEntry> contents) {
    for (FilesystemEntry entry : contents) {
        new Thread(new Runnable() {
            @Override
            public void run() {
                ContentValues values = new ContentValues();
                values.put(COLUMN_1, entry.attr1);
                values.put(COLUMN_2, entry.attr2);
                // etc.
                mContentResolver.insert(MyContentProvider.CONTENT_URI, values);
            }
        }).run();
    }
}

And just for good measure, I've also tried both of those solutions with the relevant code in the doInBackground method of another AsyncTask. Finally, I've explicitly defined MyContentProvider as living in a separate process in my AndroidManifest.xml:

<provider android:name=".MyContentProvider" android:process=":remote"/>

It runs fine, but it still seems to run in the UI thread. That's the point where I really started tearing my hair out over this, because that doesn't make any sense at all to me. No matter what I do, the UI always hangs during the inserts. Is there any way to get them not to?

Answer 1

Instead of calling mContentResolver.insert(), use AsyncQueryHandler and its startInsert() method. AsyncQueryHandler is designed to facilitate asynchronous ContentResolver queries.

Answer 2

I think your original problem may have been that you are calling the run method on your new thread (which causes execution to continue on the current thread) instead of calling the start method. I think this is what Bright Great was trying to say in his/her answer. See Difference between running and starting a thread. It's a common mistake.

Answer 3

Man.Relax yourself.And anything would looks better. At first,Start a Thread is Func start not Func run,if you want to start the new Thread not only call the func run.

new Thread(Runnable runnable).start();

Then I bet use Handler sometimes would be better than AsyncTask.

Answer 4

You can run the query in the doInBackground(Integer int) overridden method of the AsynTask, and update the main UI on the onPostExecute(Integer int) method.