Why does Process.fork make stuff slower in Ruby on OS X?

问题

Can someone explain to me why Process.fork makes stuff so much slower in Ruby? I'm using Ruby 2.3.1 on OS X El Capitan.

require 'time'
require 'benchmark'

def do_stuff
  50000.times { Time.parse(Time.utc(2016).iso8601) }
end

puts Benchmark.measure { do_stuff } # => 1.660000   0.010000   1.670000 (  1.675466)

Process.fork do
  puts Benchmark.measure { do_stuff } # => 3.170000   6.250000   9.420000 (  9.508235)
end

EDIT: Just noticed that running that code on Linux (tested Debian or Ubuntu) does not result in a negative performance impact.

回答1:

"Why does Process.fork make stuff slower in Ruby on OS X?"

Step one in getting to the bottom of this is to reduce the number of variables.

Your example of running Time.parse(Time.utc(2016).iso8601) fifty thousand times seems oddly specific. I reformulated the benchmark test using a different "slow" Ruby task:

require 'benchmark'

def do_stuff
  a = [nil] * 200

  10.times do
    a.each {|x| a.each {|y| a.each {|z| ; }}}; ()
  end
end

puts "main: #{Benchmark.measure { do_stuff }}"

Process.fork do
  puts "fork: #{Benchmark.measure { do_stuff }}"
end

Here I've replaced your Time commands with a no-op nested loop over a large array.

The results:

main:   4.020000   0.010000   4.030000 (  4.050664)
fork:   3.940000   0.000000   3.940000 (  3.962207)

main:   3.840000   0.010000   3.850000 (  3.856188)
fork:   3.850000   0.000000   3.850000 (  3.865250)

main:   3.930000   0.000000   3.930000 (  3.937741)
fork:   3.970000   0.000000   3.970000 (  3.986397)

main:   4.340000   0.010000   4.350000 (  4.370009)
fork:   4.300000   0.000000   4.300000 (  4.308156)

No noticeable pattern of the forked process being slower or faster. I've tested in Ruby 1.9, 2.0, and 2.3 on both OS X and Ubuntu, and it remains the same.

The answer to your question is:

Process.fork does not, in general, make stuff slower in Ruby on OS X.

However, there is a different interesting question here, which is Why is `Time.utc` slower in a forked process in Ruby on OS X (and not in Python)?

来源：https://stackoverflow.com/questions/38844392/why-does-process-fork-make-stuff-slower-in-ruby-on-os-x

标签

ruby