C++1y no viable conversion from std::bind to std::function

Question

I am trying to store a forward function into std::function. If I use std::bind, I get error message like no viable conversion from .... If I use lambda, it compile okay.

Here is sample code

#include <functional>

template<typename Handler>void func1(int a, Handler&& handler) {}
template<typename Handler>void func2(Handler&& handler)
{
    // this line compile fine
    std::function<void ()> funcA = [handler = std::move(handler)]() { func1(1, std::move(handler)); };
    // this line got compile error
    std::function<void ()> funcB = std::bind(func1<Handler>, 1, std::move(handler));
}

int main()
{
    func2(&main); // this just a sample, I am using functor as argument in real code
}

Trying both g++ --std=c++1y (v4.9.0) and clang++ --std=c++1y (v3.4.1) yield the same result

edit: clang++ error message

main.cpp:8:28: error: no viable conversion from 'typename _Bind_helper<__is_socketlike<void (*)(int, int (*&&)())>::value, void (*)(int, int
      (*&&)()), int, int (*)()>::type' (aka '_Bind<__func_type (typename decay<int>::type, typename decay<int (*)()>::type)>') to
      'std::function<void ()>'
    std::function<void ()> funcB = std::bind(&func1<Handler>, 1, std::move(handler));
                           ^       ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
main.cpp:14:5: note: in instantiation of function template specialization 'func2<int (*)()>' requested here
    func2(&main);
    ^
/usr/bin/../lib64/gcc/x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu/4.9.0/../../../../include/c++/4.9.0/functional:2181:7: note: candidate constructor not viable: no
      known conversion from 'typename _Bind_helper<__is_socketlike<void (*)(int, int (*&&)())>::value, void (*)(int, int (*&&)()), int, int
      (*)()>::type' (aka '_Bind<__func_type (typename decay<int>::type, typename decay<int (*)()>::type)>') to 'nullptr_t' for 1st argument
      function(nullptr_t) noexcept
      ^
/usr/bin/../lib64/gcc/x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu/4.9.0/../../../../include/c++/4.9.0/functional:2192:7: note: candidate constructor not viable: no
      known conversion from 'typename _Bind_helper<__is_socketlike<void (*)(int, int (*&&)())>::value, void (*)(int, int (*&&)()), int, int
      (*)()>::type' (aka '_Bind<__func_type (typename decay<int>::type, typename decay<int (*)()>::type)>') to 'const std::function<void ()> &'
      for 1st argument
      function(const function& __x);
      ^
/usr/bin/../lib64/gcc/x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu/4.9.0/../../../../include/c++/4.9.0/functional:2201:7: note: candidate constructor not viable: no
      known conversion from 'typename _Bind_helper<__is_socketlike<void (*)(int, int (*&&)())>::value, void (*)(int, int (*&&)()), int, int
      (*)()>::type' (aka '_Bind<__func_type (typename decay<int>::type, typename decay<int (*)()>::type)>') to 'std::function<void ()> &&' for
      1st argument
      function(function&& __x) : _Function_base()
      ^
/usr/bin/../lib64/gcc/x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu/4.9.0/../../../../include/c++/4.9.0/functional:2226:2: note: candidate template ignored:
      substitution failure [with _Functor = std::_Bind<void (*(int, int (*)()))(int, int (*&&)())>]: no matching function for call to object of
      type 'std::_Bind<void (*(int, int (*)()))(int, int (*&&)())>'
        function(_Functor);
        ^
1 error generated.

Answer 1

INTRODUCTION

std::bind will try to call func1<Handler> with an lvalue-reference, but your instantiation of func1 will make it only accept rvalues.

---

EXPLANATION

Here we have reduced your testcase to the bare minimum to show what is going on, the snippet below is ill-formed and an explanation will follow to why that is.

#include <functional>

template<class T>
void foobar (T&& val);

int main() {
  std::function<void()> f = std::bind (&foobar<int>, std::move (123));
}

In the above we will instantiate foobar with T = int, which makes the type of argument val to be an rvalue-reference to int (int&&).

std::move(123) will move-construct our value to be stored inside the object created by std::bind, but the Standard says that when std::bind later invokes the stored function, all arguments are passed as TiD cv &; ie. as lvalues.

This behavior is mandated by the Standard (n3797), as stated in section [func.bind.bind]p10.

By changing the previous ill-formed snippet into the following, no error will be raised, since foobar<int> now accepts an lvalue-reference; suitable to be bound to the lvalue passed to our function by the function-object returned by std::bind.

  std::function<void()> f = std::bind (&foobar<int&>, std::move (123));

---

???

#include <functional>
#include <type_traits>
#include <iostream>

int main() {
  auto is_lvalue = [](auto&& x) {
    return std::is_lvalue_reference<decltype(x)> { };
  };

  auto check = std::bind (is_lvalue, std::move (123));
  bool res   = check (); // res = true
}

Answer 2

in short: function has to be copyable. bind with rvalue returns non-copyable object. Workaround is to capture/bind with shared_ptr containing abovementioned value