Injecting Collection of Classes with Guice

Question

I\'m trying to inject things with Google Guice 2.0 and I have the following structure:

FooAction implements Action
BarAction implements Action

Answer 1

What you want for this is Multibindings. Specifically, you want to bind a Set<Action> (not a List, but a Set is probably what you really want anyway) like this:

Multibinder<Action> actionBinder = Multibinder.newSetBinder(binder(), Action.class);
actionBinder.addBinding().to(FooAction.class);
actionBinder.addBinding().to(BarAction.class);

Then you can @Inject the Set<Action> anywhere.

Answer 2

Let me show you what I consider an even better way of multibinding things. If you want Actions to be pluggable and let anyone add them, it's often useful to provide a simple Module for someone to use that hides needing to instantiate the Multibinder. Here's an example:

public abstract class ActionModule extends AbstractModule {
  private Multibinder<Action> actionBinder;

  @Override protected void configure() {
    actionBinder = Multibinder.newSetBinder(binder(), Action.class);
    configureActions();
  }

  /**
   * Override this method to call {@link #bindAction}.
   */
  protected abstract void configureActions();

  protected final LinkedBindingBuilder<Action> bindAction() {
    return actionBinder.addBinding();
  }
}

Now why is this better? It allows someone to use an ActionModule from anywhere to add more Actions via the standard binding API. I think it's more readable. Here's an example usage:

public final class MyStandardActionModule extends ActionModule() {
  @Override protected void configureActions() {
    bindAction().to(FooAction.class);
    bindAction().to(BarAction.class);
    // If you need to instantiate an action through a Provider, do this.
    bindAction().toProvider(BazActionProvider.class);
    // You can also scope stuff:
    bindAction().to(MySingletonAction.class).in(Singleton.class);
  }
}

This pattern of using a Module to hide the multibinder is used in Guice code. It's a little work up front, but keeps things clean. You can also do something similar for a MapBinder if you need to. Keep in mind you can instantiate as many ActionModules as you want.