Script via Plink in .bat behaves differently

Question

I have a .bat file on my Windows machine. This .bat file uses plink.exe to connect to an Ubuntu machine and execute an .sh

Answer 1

In the other cases, you are using interactive sessions.

While the Plink uses non-interactive session by default, when you specify a command on its command-line.

Your script probably relies on some environment variables (like PATH) being set specifically.

It's quite probable that the variables are set only for interactive sessions. Probably because they are modified in a startup script that is executed (sourced) for the the interactive sessions only.

Solutions are:

• Correct the startup scripts to modify the variables unconditionally (even for non-interactive sessions).

• Modify the script not to rely on environment variables.

  Or you can source the profile script, see Unable to run shell script with ktutil command from Windows using PLINK.

• Force the Plink to use the interactive session using the -t switch

  This is not a recommended solution, as using the interactive session to automate a command execution can bring you nasty side effects. See for example Is there a simple way to get rid of junk values that come when you SSH using Python's Paramiko library and fetch output from CLI of a remote machine?

---

Some more obscure SSH servers can also behave differently when "exec" channel is used to execute the command. See Executing command on Plink command line fails with "not found".

Answer 2

I had to hack a solution to work around this problem. Adding a "-i" option at the header of the bash script I was invoking from my .bat file did the trick:

#!/bin/bash -i

Note some warn of unwanted side effects (no mention of specifics tho...) when using this option. But calling this now interactive script from a remote ssh session (e.g. when using plink.exe from a Windows .bat file and passing inline commands to the Unix box) solves any issues regarding file/directory visibility & permission issues.

Note to plink users: if you're calling a script on Unix via plink and noticing that the script doesn't behave as expected...adding the "-i" may help debug/solve your problem. Again, note that some have claimed unwanted side-effects of this hack of which they/I'm unaware.