HTTP Response before Request

Question

My question might sound stupid, but I just wanted to be sure:

• Is it possible to send an HTTP response before having the request for that resource?

Answer 1

If someone requests /index.html and you send two responses (one for /index.html and the other for /img.jpg), how do you know the recipient will get the two responses and know what to do with them before the second request goes in?

The problem is not really with the sending. The problem is with the receiver possibly getting unexpected data.

One other issue is that you're denying the client the ability to use HTTP caching tools like If-Modified-Since and If-None-Match (i.e. the client might not want /img.jpg to be sent because it already has a cached copy).

That said, you can approximate the server-push benefits by using Comet techniques. But that is much more involved than simply anticipating incoming HTTP requests.

Answer 2

No it is not possible.

The first line of the request holds the resource being requested so you wouldn't know what to respond with unless you examined the bytes (at least one line's worth) of the request first.

Answer 3

A recent post by Jacques Mattheij, referencing your very question, claims that although HTTP was designed as a synchronous protocol, the implementation was not. In practise the browser (he doesn't specify which exactly) accepts answers to requests have not been sent yet.

On the other hand, if you are looking to something less hacky, you could have a look at :

• push techniques that allows the server to send content to the browser. The modern implementation that replace long-polling/Comet "hacks" are the websockets. You may want to have a look at socket.io also.
• Alternatively you may want to have a look at client-side routing. Some implementations combine this with caching techniques (like in derby.js I believe).

Answer 4

You're looking for server push: it isn't available in HTTP. Protocols like SPDY have it, but you're out of luck if you're restricted to HTTP.

Answer 5

I don't think it is possible to mix .html and image in the same HTTP response. As for sending image data 'immediately', right after the first request - there is a concept of 'static resources' which could be of help (but it will require client to create a new reqest for a specific resource).

There are couple of interesting things mentioned in the the article.

Answer 6

You'll get a better result by caching resources effectively, i.e. setting proper cache headers and configuring your web server for caching. You can also inline images using base 64 encoding, if that's a specific concern.

You can also look at long polling javascript solutions.