tcl array question - key with quotes

Question

this surprised me

>set foo(\"bar\") 12
12
>parray foo
foo(\"bar\") = 12
>set foo(bar) 12
12
>parray foo
foo(\"bar\") = 12
foo(bar)   = 12
         


        

Answer 1

The " character is only special to Tcl's parser at the start of a word (or the end of a word that was started by ", of course). In fact, if you'd put spaces in you would have got an error:

% set foo("b a r") 2
wrong # args: should be "set varName ?newValue?"

In the case where you're doing the string length calls, the " is at the start of a word so it is special. If we put an extra leading junk character, we see that the specialness of " goes away:

% string length x"bar"
6

If you're doing something complicated with array indices, I think it's usually easier to put the name of the element in a variable itself, since then it's clearer what's going on (and usually easier to debug too):

set idx "bar"
set foo($idx) 12