I have a controller in MVC serving up images from a database.
EDIT: This still happens if I serve up a file over completely standard means in MVC.
Eve
You should set the Expires header to tell the browser how long it should use its local copy.
It appears for me that Chrome requests a favicon for its own tabs - I kept getting 404s (because my favicon is somwhere else and my pages know it) till I did some tests and realized it was Chrome making direct requests to the favicon file. No real fix except making a rewrite to the real file I guess
Chrome browser could work with Google site in another way than with any other site, so, at first, I would recommend to check if it looks for favicon.ico every time somewhere else, for example, on StackOverflow.
I would also check if Firefox does the same with your site. I think favicon.ico should be requested only one time per browser run even if it isn't present on site. This could be bug in Chrome version you use.
This has nothing to do with MVC. I am using webforms with a custom built log service and I stumbled upon this post wondering why I had continuous 'File does not exist' errors in my logs. This is locally on my development machine, I have no favicon.ico files in my projects, and I have tried IE, Firefox and Google trying to see which browser is the guilty party.
Every request from Google Chrome to my apps makes a request for a favicon.ico. I had to start logging browser locally to determine that it was in fact googles browser that is the culprit. I'd contact google if it bothers you. I just wanted to make sure it wasn't some new trojan infecting my chrome.
one thing you could do is have MVC ignore any request for *.ico so that you don't get any exceptions while debugging.
Should be something like this:
routes.MapRoute("ignore-favicon", "{*path}", null, new {path = ".*/favicon\\.ico"});
That URL pattern matches everything, but then we constrain it to only match anything ending in favicon.ico. (I haven't tested this)
This SO question/answer explains how to serve the Favicon to the browser by using routes.