Use of joinTransaction in JPA

Question

The following code is from JPA specs. I could not understand why em.joinTransaction() is required in createLineItem(int quantity).

Answer 1

First, a few words of theory...

An application-managed entity manager participates in a JTA transaction in one of two ways.

1. If the persistence context is created inside the transaction, the persistence provider will automatically synchronize the persistence context with the transaction.
2. If the persistence context was created earlier (outside of a transaction or in a transaction that has since ended), the persistence context can be manually synchronized with the transaction by calling joinTransaction() on the EntityManager interface. Once synchronized, the persistence context will automatically be flushed when the transaction commits.

After reading the above definition a few questions may arise:

• how do we know that ShoppingCartImpl participates in JTA transaction ?
  
  Because the class has been annotated with @Stateful (or @Stateless) annotation so the intention is to execute the class within Java EE environment which by default uses JTA transactions. A class doesn't need such annotation, if it will be executed in Java SE environment.

• how do we know application-managed entity manager is used in this particular case?
  
  Because we are using @PersistenceUnit annotation to inject EntityManagerFactory and then manually creating and destroying EntityManager. By doing this we are telling Java EE container that we don't want our transaction to be automatically managed (like in case of transaction-scoped entity manager or extended entity manager types).

• why em.joinTransaction() is required in createLineItem method?
  
  By calling em.joinTransaction() we notify the application-managed persistence context that it should synchronize itself with the current JTA transaction. Without such call the changes to Order would not be flushed to the underlying database when the transaction commits (at the end of createLineItem method).
  
  NOTE: since EntityManagerFactory instances are thread-safe and EntityManager instances are not, an application must not call em.joinTransaction() on the same entity manager in multiple concurrent transactions.