Why can't I check if a 'DateTime' is 'Nothing'?

Question

In VB.NET, is there a way to set a DateTime variable to \"not set\"? And why is it possible to set a DateTime to Nothing, but not<

Answer 1

In any programming language, be careful when using Nulls. The example above shows another issue. If you use a type of Nullable, that means that the variables instantiated from that type can hold the value System.DBNull.Value; not that it has changed the interpretation of setting the value to default using "= Nothing" or that the Object of the value can now support a null reference. Just a warning... happy coding!

You could create a separate class containing a value type. An object created from such a class would be a reference type, which could be assigned Nothing. An example:

Public Class DateTimeNullable
Private _value As DateTime

'properties
Public Property Value() As DateTime
    Get
        Return _value
    End Get
    Set(ByVal value As DateTime)
        _value = value
    End Set
End Property

'constructors
Public Sub New()
    Value = DateTime.MinValue
End Sub

Public Sub New(ByVal dt As DateTime)
    Value = dt
End Sub

'overridables
Public Overrides Function ToString() As String
    Return Value.ToString()
End Function

End Class

'in Main():

        Dim dtn As DateTimeNullable = Nothing
    Dim strTest1 As String = "Falied"
    Dim strTest2 As String = "Failed"
    If dtn Is Nothing Then strTest1 = "Succeeded"

    dtn = New DateTimeNullable(DateTime.Now)
    If dtn Is Nothing Then strTest2 = "Succeeded"

    Console.WriteLine("test1: " & strTest1)
    Console.WriteLine("test2: " & strTest2)
    Console.WriteLine(".ToString() = " & dtn.ToString())
    Console.WriteLine(".Value.ToString() = " & dtn.Value.ToString())

    Console.ReadKey()

    ' Output:
    'test1:  Succeeded()
    'test2:  Failed()
    '.ToString() = 4/10/2012 11:28:10 AM
    '.Value.ToString() = 4/10/2012 11:28:10 AM

Then you could pick and choose overridables to make it do what you need. Lot of work - but if you really need it, you can do it.

Answer 2

You can check this like below :

if varDate = "#01/01/0001#" then
       '  blank date. do something.
else
       ' Date is not blank. Do some other thing
end if

Answer 3

DateTime is a value type, which means it always has some value.

It's like an integer - it can be 0, or 1, or less than zero, but it can never be "nothing".

If you want a DateTime that can take the value Nothing, use a Nullable DateTime.

Answer 4

This is one of the biggest sources of confusion with VB.Net, IMO.

Nothing in VB.Net is the equivalent of default(T) in C#: the default value for the given type.

• For value types, this is essentially the equivalent of 'zero': 0 for Integer, False for Boolean, DateTime.MinValue for DateTime, ...
• For reference types, it is the null value (a reference that refers to, well, nothing).

The statement d Is Nothing is therefore equivalent to d Is DateTime.MinValue, which obviously does not compile.

Solutions: as others have said

• Either use DateTime? (i.e. Nullable(Of DateTime)). This is my preferred solution.
• Or use d = DateTime.MinValue or equivalently d = Nothing

In the context of the original code, you could use:

Dim d As DateTime? = Nothing
Dim boolNotSet As Boolean = d.HasValue

A more comprehensive explanation can be found on Anthony D. Green's blog

Answer 5

Some examples on working with nullable DateTime values.

(See Nullable Value Types (Visual Basic) for more.)

'
' An ordinary DateTime declaration. It is *not* nullable. Setting it to
' 'Nothing' actually results in a non-null value.
'
Dim d1 As DateTime = Nothing
Console.WriteLine(String.Format("d1 = [{0}]\n", d1))
' Output:  d1 = [1/1/0001 12:00:00 AM]

' Console.WriteLine(String.Format("d1 is Nothing? [{0}]\n", (d1 Is Nothing)))
'
'   Compilation error on above expression '(d1 Is Nothing)':
'
'      'Is' operator does not accept operands of type 'Date'.
'       Operands must be reference or nullable types.

'
' Three different but equivalent ways to declare a DateTime
' nullable:
'
Dim d2? As DateTime = Nothing
Console.WriteLine(String.Format("d2 = [{0}][{1}]\n", d2, (d2 Is Nothing)))
' Output:  d2 = [][True]

Dim d3 As DateTime? = Nothing
Console.WriteLine(String.Format("d3 = [{0}][{1}]\n", d3, (d3 Is Nothing)))
' Output:  d3 = [][True]

Dim d4 As Nullable(Of DateTime) = Nothing
Console.WriteLine(String.Format("d4 = [{0}][{1}]\n", d4, (d4 Is Nothing)))
' Output:  d4 = [][True]

Also, on how to check whether a variable is null (from Nothing (Visual Basic)):

When checking whether a reference (or nullable value type) variable is null, do not use = Nothing or <> Nothing. Always use Is Nothing or IsNot Nothing.

Answer 6

You can also use below just simple to check:

If startDate <> Nothing Then
your logic
End If

It will check that the startDate variable of DateTime datatype is null or not.