Why does javascript map function return undefined?

Question

My code

 var arr = [\'a\',\'b\',1];
 var results = arr.map(function(item){
                if(typeof item ===\'string\'){return item;}  
               });
<         


        

Answer 1

Since ES6 filter supports pointy arrow notation (like LINQ):

So it can be boiled down to following one-liner.

['a','b',1].filter(item => typeof item ==='string');

Answer 2

Filter works for this specific case where the items are not modified. But in many cases when you use map you want to make some modification to the items passed.

if that is your intent, you can use reduce:

var arr = ['a','b',1];
var results = arr.reduce((results, item) => {
    if (typeof item === 'string') results.push(modify(item)) // modify is a fictitious function that would apply some change to the items in the array
    return results
}, [])

Answer 3

You aren't returning anything in the case that the item is not a string. In that case, the function returns undefined, what you are seeing in the result.

The map function is used to map one value to another, but it looks you actually want to filter the array, which a map function is not suitable for.

What you actually want is a filter function. It takes a function that returns true or false based on whether you want the item in the resulting array or not.

var arr = ['a','b',1];
var results = arr.filter(function(item){
    return typeof item ==='string';  
});

Answer 4

My solution would be to use filter after the map.

This should support every JS data type.

example:

const notUndefined = anyValue => typeof anyValue !== 'undefined'    
const noUndefinedList = someList
          .map(// mapping condition)
          .filter(notUndefined); // by doing this, 
                      //you can ensure what's returned is not undefined

Answer 5

var arr = ['a','b',1];
 var results = arr.filter(function(item){
                if(typeof item ==='string'){return item;}  
               });

Answer 6

You only return a value if the current element is a string. Perhaps assigning an empty string otherwise will suffice:

var arr = ['a','b',1];
var results = arr.map(function(item){
    return (typeof item ==='string') ? item : '';  
});

Of course, if you want to filter any non-string elements, you shouldn't use map(). Rather, you should look into using the filter() function.