Preserve Python tuples with JSON

Question

I\'m still a little new to this, so I might not know all the conventional terms for things:

Is it possible to preserve Python tuples when encoding with JSON? Right

Answer 1

It is with simplejson

import simplejson

def _to_json(python_object) :
    if isinstance(python_object, tuple) :
        python_object = {'__class__': 'tuple',
                         '__value__': list(python_object)}
    else :
        raise TypeError(repr(python_object) + ' is not JSON serializable') 

    return python_object

def _from_json(json_object):                                   
    if json_object['__class__'] == 'tuple':
        return tuple(json_object['__value__'])
    return json_object


jsn = simplejson.dumps((1,2,3), 
                       default=_to_json, 
                       tuple_as_array=False)

tpl = simplejson.loads(jsn, object_hook=_from_json)

Answer 2

Pavel Anossov answered the question well. To encode objects such as tuples the code works. Having tuples as Python dict keys is also useful, and the code above does not handle tuples as dict keys. To manage tuples as keys, a boolean flag signifying if tuple is a dict key can be used and tuple gets wrapped in a layer of json.dumps(...) output; during decode, json gets taken care of by recursion.

Solution can allow to pass data structures of tuple vs value that enables easier hashing. Python def __hash__(self): frequently returns the hash of tuple of items in an object, and sometimes it is useful to have simpler data structures not wrapped in classes.

1. hint_tuples can have a named argument dict_key -- flag for tuple being a dict key. Python dict type cannot be a key to dict, better to turn it to a string with json.dumps(...), during decoding this should be restored to dict and recursion should take care of it being turned into tuple.
2. optionally __tuple__ can be obfuscated so that in case someone encodes a string __tuple__ as part of dict key it can pass through encoder / decoder.

Code below is what I came up with to take care of encoding tuples in Python dict keys. A couple of basic tests are included as part of __main__ to demonstrate the solution. Readability of encoding output is forgone to increase the number of cases that pass through the solution.

    # Pavel Anossov's solution hinted this:
    
    import json
    tuple_signifier = '__tuple__s_i_g_n_i_f_i_e_r__'
    
    class StreamTuple(dict):
         def __hash__(self):
             return hash(str(self))
    
    class MultiDimensionalArrayEncoder(json.JSONEncoder):
        def encode(self, obj):
            def hint_tuples(item, dict_key=False):
                global tuple_signifier
                ret_val = None
                if isinstance(item, tuple):
                    if dict_key:
                        ret_val = json.dumps(dict(
                            [(
                                tuple_signifier,
                                json.dumps(hint_tuples(list(item))),
                            ),],
                        ))
                    else:
                        ret_val = dict(
                            [(
                                tuple_signifier,
                                json.dumps(hint_tuples(list(item))),
                            ),],
                        )
    
                elif isinstance(item, list):
                    ret_val = [hint_tuples(e) for e in item]
                elif isinstance(item, dict):
                    ret_val = dict([
                        (hint_tuples(key, dict_key=True), hint_tuples(value))
                        for key, value in item.items()
                    ])
                else:
                    ret_val = item
                return ret_val
            return super(MultiDimensionalArrayEncoder, self).\
                         encode(hint_tuples(obj))
    
    
    def hinted_tuple_hook(obj):
        global tuple_signifier
    
        ret_val = {}
        if tuple_signifier in obj:
            ret_val = tuple(json.loads(obj[tuple_signifier], object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,))
        else:
            for k, v in obj.items():
                inner_k = k
                inner_v = v
                if isinstance(k, str) and tuple_signifier in k:
                    inner_k = json.loads(k, object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,)
                if isinstance(v, str) and tuple_signifier in v:
                    inner_v = json.loads(v, object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,)
                ret_val[inner_k] = inner_v
        return ret_val
    
    #
    # Some tests that show how to use the above hinted tuple hook to encode 
    # / decode Python tuples.
    #
    if __name__ == '__main__':
        enc = MultiDimensionalArrayEncoder()
        test_input_1 = (2,)
        test_input_2 = {(2,): 'a'}
        test_input_3 = {'a': {(2,): {1:'a'}}}
        print('test_input_1 encoded:', enc.encode(test_input_1), test_input_1)
        print('test_input_1 decoded:',
            json.loads(enc.encode(test_input_1),
                object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,)
        )
    #"""
        print('test_input_2 encoded:', enc.encode(test_input_2))
        print('test_input_2 decoded:',
            json.loads(enc.encode(test_input_2),
                object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,)
        )
    
        print('\n' * 3)
        print('test_input_3 encoded:', enc.encode(test_input_3))
        print('test_input_3 decoded:',
            json.loads(enc.encode(test_input_3),
                object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,)
        )
    
        print('\n' * 3)
        test_input_4 = {'a': 'b'}
        print('test_input_4  encoded:', enc.encode(test_input_4))
        print('test_input_4 decoded:',
            json.loads(enc.encode(test_input_4),
                object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook,)
        )
    
        #"""

Answer 3

Nope, it's not possible. There is no concept of a tuple in the JSON format (see here for a concise breakdown of what types exist in JSON). Python's json module converts Python tuples to JSON lists because that's the closest thing in JSON to a tuple.

You haven't given much detail of your use case here, but if you need to store string representations of data structures that include tuples, a few possibilities immediately come to mind, which may or may not be appropriate depending upon your situation:

1. Create your own encoding and decoding functions
2. Use pickle (careful; pickle.loads isn't safe to use on user-provided input).
3. Use repr and ast.literal_eval instead of json.dumps and json.loads. repr will give you output reasonably similar in appearance to json.dumps, but repr will not convert tuples to lists. ast.literal_eval is a less powerful, more secure version of eval which will only decode strings, numbers, tuples, lists, dicts, booleans, and None.

Option 3 is probably the easiest and simplest solution for you.

Answer 4

The principal difference between python lists and tuples is mutability, which is irrelevant to JSON representations, as long as you're not contemplating modifying the internal members of the JSON list while it's in text form. You can just turn the lists you get back into tuples. If you're not using any custom object decoders, the only structured datatypes you have to consider are JSON objects and arrays, which come out as python dicts and lists.

def tuplify(listything):
    if isinstance(listything, list): return tuple(map(tuplify, listything))
    if isinstance(listything, dict): return {k:tuplify(v) for k,v in listything.items()}
    return listything

If you are specializing the decoding, or want some JSON arrays to be python lists and others to be python tuples, you'll need to wrap data items in a dict or tuple that annotates type information. This in itself is a better way to influence an algorithm's control flow than branching based on whether something is a list or tuple (or some other iterable type).

Answer 5

You can write a highly-specialzed encoder and a decoder hook:

import json

class MultiDimensionalArrayEncoder(json.JSONEncoder):
    def encode(self, obj):
        def hint_tuples(item):
            if isinstance(item, tuple):
                return {'__tuple__': True, 'items': item}
            if isinstance(item, list):
                return [hint_tuples(e) for e in item]
            if isinstance(item, dict):
                return {key: hint_tuples(value) for key, value in item.items()}
            else:
                return item

        return super(MultiDimensionalArrayEncoder, self).encode(hint_tuples(obj))

def hinted_tuple_hook(obj):
    if '__tuple__' in obj:
        return tuple(obj['items'])
    else:
        return obj


enc = MultiDimensionalArrayEncoder()
jsonstring =  enc.encode([1, 2, (3, 4), [5, 6, (7, 8)]])

print jsonstring

# [1, 2, {"items": [3, 4], "__tuple__": true}, [5, 6, {"items": [7, 8], "__tuple__": true}]]

print json.loads(jsonstring, object_hook=hinted_tuple_hook)

# [1, 2, (3, 4), [5, 6, (7, 8)]]