Best Practice for Designing User Roles and Permission System?

Question

I need to add user roles and permission system into my web application built using PHP/MySQL. I want to have this functionality:

1. One root user can create sub-

Answer 1

You might not want groups of permissions. Instead create user groups, give user groups permissions, and put users in groups. Users should also be able to override permissions from the groups they are in. Deny should always override grant where a user is in more than one group with the pemission.

In summary:

• User has zero or more permissions (grany, deny)
• User is in zero or more groups
• Group has zero or more permissions (grant, deny)

Answer 2

I have groups and users (like active directory LDAP solution). So if I give access to group I need that users in this group have herited accesses.

So, based on the @suresh-kamrushi answer below, I made this :

INSERT INTO `permission` (`bit`, `name`) VALUES
(1,   'add-yes'),
(2,   'add-no'),
(4,   'edit-yes'),
(8,   'edit-no'),
(16,  'del-yes'),
(32,  'del-no'),
(64,  'view-yes'),
(128, 'view-no');

If user have bit 00000000, I take first two digits 00 that means add-yes and add-no are herited from group permissions.

If user have bit 01010110, I take first two digits 01 that means add-no will prime on group permissions, so this user have no add permission. This bitwise says that user can only view.

It's also working with parent groups.

What do you think about this solution ? Does anyone have got better way for that ?

Answer 3

I Think bitwise operator are the best way to implement user permission. Here I am showing how we can implement it with MySQL.

Below is a sample tables with some sample data:

Table 1: Permission table to store permission name along with it bit like 1, 2, 4, 8.. etc (multiple of 2)

CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `permission` (
  `bit` int(11) NOT NULL,
  `name` varchar(50) NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`bit`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=latin1;

Insert some sample data into the table.

INSERT INTO `permission` (`bit`, `name`) VALUES
(1, 'User-Add'),
(2, 'User-Edit'),
(4, 'User-Delete'),
(8, 'User-View'),
(16, 'Blog-Add'),
(32, 'Blog-Edit'),
(64, 'Blog-Delete'),
(128, 'Blog-View');

Table 2: User table to store user id,name and role. Role will be calculated as sum of permissions.
Example:

If user 'Ketan' having permission of 'User-Add' (bit=1) and 'Blog-Delete' (bit-64) so role will be 65 (1+64).
If user 'Mehata' having permission of 'Blog-View' (bit=128) and 'User-Delete' (bit-4) so role will be 132 (128+4).

CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `user` (
  `id` int(11) NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
  `name` varchar(50) NOT NULL,
  `role` int(11) NOT NULL,
  `created_date` datetime NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY (`id`)
) ENGINE=InnoDB  DEFAULT CHARSET=latin1;

Sample data-

INSERT INTO `user` (`id`, `name`, `role`, `created_date`)
   VALUES (NULL, 'Ketan', '65', '2013-01-09 00:00:00'),
   (NULL, 'Mehata', '132', '2013-01-09 00:00:00');

Loding permission of user After login if we want to load user permission then we can query below to get the permissions:

SELECT permission.bit,permission.name  
   FROM user LEFT JOIN permission ON user.role & permission.bit
 WHERE user.id = 1

Here user.role "&" permission.bit is a Bitwise operator which will give output as -

User-Add - 1
Blog-Delete - 64

If we want to check weather a particular user have user-edit permission or not-

  SELECT * FROM `user` 
     WHERE role & (select bit from permission where name='user-edit')

Output = No rows.

You can see also: http://sforsuresh.in/implemention-of-user-permission-with-php-mysql-bitwise-operators/

Answer 4

I had a slightly different structure, but it should be able to serve as a reference.

Each user has a 'Role', 'GroupID' associate with it, and Group table for which the GroupID refers to. Then I have 3 permission table.

PermissionMaster(FormName)

PermissionChild(PermissionMasterID, PermissionName, Desc, DefaultValue, DependOn) and

PermissionGroupChild(GroupID, PermissionChildID, Allow)

PermissionMaster holds the name/form/module for which the permission refers to. PermissionChild will list all the possible permission available for each Master, such as 'Create', 'View', 'Edit', 'Delete', and description (I didn't have this on the first version, and it started to get confusing when there's too many permission setup even for 1 module). I allow adding more children to specifically refer to some function like 'ChangeTimeStamp', which would also allow more specific permission then 'Edit'

Then PermissionGroupChild is the link between PermissionChild and Group table. Every group will have a set of PermissionChild copied and set with default setting. Then I had a permission class which does the table query and check for each user. I only load it during login. Then in every form/module, I check for it's appropriate permission and applies the UI properly.

As for role, I only use it at the Login configuration page. Smaller Role value means higher ranked. So user can only see itself and those of Role value higher than itself. He/she can edit those of lower rank than itself but not similar.

Answer 5

The pattern that suits your needs is called role-based access control.

There are several good implementations in PHP, including Zend_Acl (good documenation), phpGACL and TinyACL. Most frameworks also have their own implementations of an ACL in some form.

Even if you choose to roll your own, it'll help you to review well factored solutions such as those.