Memory Efficiency and Performance of String.Replace .NET Framework

Question

 string str1 = \"12345ABC...\\\\...ABC100000\"; 
 // Hypothetically huge string of 100000 + Unicode Chars
 str1 = str1.Replace(\"1\", string.Empty);
 str1 = str1.Rep         


        

Answer 1

StringBuilder: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/2839d5h5.aspx

The performance of the Replace operation itself should be roughly same as string.Replace and according to Microsoft no garbage should be produced.

Answer 2

StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder("Hello string");
sb.Replace("string", String.Empty);
Console.WriteLine(sb);  

StringBuilder, a mutable string.

Answer 3

I've ended up in this thread a couple of times now and I haven't been totally convinced after reading the previous answers since some of the benchmarks was done with a StopWatch which might give some kind of indication but does not feel great.

My use case is that I have a string that might be quite big ie a HTML output from a website. I need to replace a number of placeholders inside this string (about 10, max 20) with values.

I created a Benchmark.NET-test to get some robust data around this and here is what I found:

TLDR:

• Don't use String.Replace if performance/memory is a concern.
• Regex.Replace is the fastest but uses slightly more memory than StringBuilder.Replace. Compiled-regex is fastest if you intend to reuse the same pattern, for low number of usage a non-compile Regex-instance is cheaper to create.
• If you only care about memory consumption and are fine with slower execution, use StringBuilder.Replace

Results from the test:

|                Method | ItemsToReplace |       Mean |     Error |    StdDev |   Gen 0 |  Gen 1 | Gen 2 | Allocated |
|---------------------- |--------------- |-----------:|----------:|----------:|--------:|-------:|------:|----------:|
|         StringReplace |              3 |  21.493 us | 0.1182 us | 0.1105 us |  3.6926 | 0.0305 |     - |  18.96 KB |
|  StringBuilderReplace |              3 |  35.383 us | 0.1341 us | 0.1119 us |  2.5024 |      - |     - |  13.03 KB |
|          RegExReplace |              3 |  19.620 us | 0.1252 us | 0.1045 us |  3.4485 | 0.0305 |     - |  17.75 KB |
| RegExReplace_Compiled |              3 |   4.573 us | 0.0318 us | 0.0282 us |  2.7084 | 0.0610 |     - |  13.91 KB |
|         StringReplace |             10 |  74.273 us | 0.7900 us | 0.7390 us | 12.2070 | 0.1221 |     - |  62.75 KB |
|  StringBuilderReplace |             10 | 115.322 us | 0.5820 us | 0.5444 us |  2.6855 |      - |     - |  13.84 KB |
|          RegExReplace |             10 |  24.121 us | 0.1130 us | 0.1002 us |  4.4250 | 0.0916 |     - |  22.75 KB |
| RegExReplace_Compiled |             10 |   8.601 us | 0.0298 us | 0.0279 us |  3.6774 | 0.1221 |     - |  18.92 KB |
|         StringReplace |             20 | 150.193 us | 1.4508 us | 1.3571 us | 24.6582 | 0.2441 |     - | 126.89 KB |
|  StringBuilderReplace |             20 | 233.984 us | 1.1707 us | 1.0951 us |  2.9297 |      - |     - |   15.3 KB |
|          RegExReplace |             20 |  28.699 us | 0.1179 us | 0.1045 us |  4.8218 | 0.0916 |     - |  24.79 KB |
| RegExReplace_Compiled |             20 |  12.672 us | 0.0599 us | 0.0560 us |  4.0894 | 0.1221 |     - |  20.95 KB |

So my conclusions is:

• Regex.Replace is the way to go for fast execution and reasonable memory usage. Use a Compiled shared instance to speed up.
• StringBuilder has the lowest memory footprint but is a lot slower than Regex.Replace. I would only use it if memory is the only thing that matters.

The code for the benchmark looks like this:

[MemoryDiagnoser]
[HtmlExporter]
[PlainExporter]
[RPlotExporter]
public class String_Replace
{
    private Dictionary<string, string> _valuesToReplace = new Dictionary<string, string>()
    {
        {"foo","fooRep" },
        {"bar","barRep" },
        {"lorem","loremRep" },
        {"ipsum","ipsumRep" },
        {"x","xRep" },
        {"y","yRep" },
        {"z","zRep" },
        {"yada","yadaRep" },
        {"old","oldRep" },
        {"new","newRep" },

        {"enim","enimRep" },
        {"amet","ametRep" },
        {"sit","sitRep" },
        {"convallis","convallisRep" },
        {"vehicula","vehiculaRep" },
        {"suspendisse","suspendisseRep" },
        {"accumsan","accumsanRep" },
        {"suscipit","suscipitRep" },
        {"ligula","ligulaRep" },
        {"posuere","posuereRep" }
    };

    private Regex _regexCompiled;

    private string GetText_With_3_Tags()
    {
        return @"<html>
        <body>
        Lorem ipsum dolor sit [foo], consectetur [bar] elit. Proin nulla quam, faucibus a ligula quis, posuere commodo elit. Nunc at tincidunt elit. Sed ipsum ex, accumsan sed viverra sit amet, tincidunt id nibh. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia curae; Nam interdum ex eget blandit lacinia. Nullam a tortor id sapien fringilla pellentesque vel ac purus. Fusce placerat dapibus tortor id luctus. Aenean in lacinia neque. Fusce quis ultrices odio. Nam id leo neque.

Etiam erat lorem, tincidunt volutpat odio at, finibus pharetra felis. Sed magna enim, accumsan at convallis a, aliquet eu quam. Vestibulum faucibus tincidunt ipsum et lacinia. Sed cursus ut arcu a commodo. Integer euismod eros at efficitur sollicitudin. In quis magna non orci sollicitudin condimentum. Fusce sed lacinia lorem, nec varius erat. In quis odio viverra, pharetra ex ac, hendrerit ante. Mauris congue enim et tellus sollicitudin pulvinar non sit amet tortor. Suspendisse at ex pharetra, semper diam ut, molestie velit. Cras lacinia urna neque, sit amet laoreet ex venenatis nec. Mauris at leo massa.

Aliquam mollis ultrices mi, sit amet venenatis enim rhoncus nec. Integer sit amet lectus tempor, finibus nisl quis, sodales ante. Curabitur suscipit dolor a dignissim consequat. Nulla eget vestibulum massa. Nam fermentum congue velit a placerat. Vivamus bibendum ex velit, id auctor ipsum bibendum eu. Praesent id gravida dui. Curabitur sollicitudin lobortis purus ac tempor. Sed felis enim, ornare et est egestas, blandit tincidunt lacus. Ut commodo dignissim augue, eget bibendum augue facilisis non.

Ut tortor neque, dignissim sit amet [lorem] ut, facilisis sit amet quam. Nullam et leo ut est congue vehicula et accumsan dolor. Aliquam erat dolor, eleifend a ipsum et, maximus suscipit ipsum. Nunc nec diam ex. Praesent suscipit aliquet condimentum. Nulla sodales lobortis fermentum. Maecenas ut laoreet sem. Ut id pulvinar urna, vel gravida lacus. Integer nunc urna, euismod eget vulputate sit amet, pharetra nec velit. Donec vel elit ac dolor varius faucibus tempus sed tortor. Donec metus diam, condimentum sit amet odio at, cursus cursus risus. Interdum et malesuada fames ac ante ipsum primis in faucibus. Nullam maximus tellus id quam consequat vestibulum. Curabitur rutrum eros tellus, eget commodo mauris sollicitudin a. In dignissim non est at pretium. Nunc bibendum pharetra dui ac ullamcorper.

Sed rutrum vehicula pretium. Morbi eu felis ante. Aliquam vel mauris at felis tempus dictum ac a justo. Suspendisse ultricies nisi turpis, non sagittis magna porttitor venenatis. Aliquam ac risus quis leo semper viverra non ac nunc. Phasellus lacinia augue sed libero elementum, at interdum nunc posuere. Duis lacinia rhoncus urna eget scelerisque. Morbi ullamcorper tempus bibendum. Proin at est eget nibh dignissim bibendum. Fusce imperdiet ut urna nec mattis. Aliquam massa mauris, consequat tristique magna non, sodales tempus massa. Ut lobortis risus rhoncus, molestie mi vitae, accumsan enim. Quisque dapibus libero elementum lectus dignissim, non finibus lacus lacinia.
        </p><p>
        </body>
        </html>";
    }

    
    private string GetText_With_10_Tags()
    {
          return @"<html>
        <body>
        Lorem ipsum dolor sit [foo], consectetur [bar] elit. Proin nulla quam, faucibus a ligula quis, posuere commodo elit. Nunc at tincidunt elit. Sed ipsum ex, accumsan sed viverra sit amet, tincidunt id nibh. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia curae; Nam interdum ex eget blandit lacinia. Nullam a tortor id sapien fringilla pellentesque vel ac purus. Fusce placerat dapibus tortor id luctus. Aenean in lacinia neque. Fusce quis ultrices odio. Nam id leo neque.

Etiam erat lorem, tincidunt volutpat odio at, finibus pharetra felis. Sed magna enim, [z] at convallis a, aliquet eu quam. Vestibulum faucibus tincidunt ipsum et lacinia. Sed cursus ut arcu a commodo. Integer euismod eros at efficitur sollicitudin. In quis magna non orci sollicitudin condimentum. Fusce sed lacinia lorem, nec varius erat. In quis odio viverra, pharetra ex ac, hendrerit ante. Mauris congue enim et tellus sollicitudin pulvinar non sit amet tortor. Suspendisse at ex pharetra, semper diam ut, molestie velit. Cras lacinia urna neque, sit amet laoreet ex venenatis nec. Mauris at leo massa.

Aliquam mollis ultrices mi, sit amet venenatis enim rhoncus nec. Integer sit amet [y] tempor, finibus nisl quis, sodales ante. Curabitur suscipit dolor a dignissim consequat. Nulla eget vestibulum massa. Nam fermentum congue velit a placerat. Vivamus bibendum ex velit, id auctor ipsum bibendum eu. Praesent id gravida dui. Curabitur sollicitudin lobortis purus ac tempor. Sed felis enim, ornare et est egestas, blandit tincidunt lacus. Ut commodo dignissim augue, eget bibendum augue facilisis non.

Ut tortor neque, dignissim sit amet [lorem] ut, [ipsum] sit amet quam. [x] et leo ut est congue [new] et accumsan dolor. Aliquam erat dolor, eleifend a ipsum et, maximus suscipit ipsum. Nunc nec diam ex. Praesent suscipit aliquet condimentum. Nulla sodales lobortis fermentum. Maecenas ut laoreet sem. Ut id pulvinar urna, vel gravida lacus. Integer nunc urna, euismod eget vulputate sit amet, pharetra nec velit. Donec vel elit ac dolor varius faucibus tempus sed tortor. Donec metus diam, condimentum sit amet odio at, cursus cursus risus. Interdum et malesuada fames ac ante ipsum primis in faucibus. Nullam maximus tellus id quam consequat vestibulum. Curabitur rutrum eros tellus, eget commodo mauris sollicitudin a. In dignissim non est at pretium. Nunc bibendum pharetra dui ac ullamcorper.

Sed rutrum vehicula pretium. Morbi eu felis ante. Aliquam vel [old] at felis [yada] dictum ac a justo. Suspendisse ultricies nisi turpis, non sagittis magna porttitor venenatis. Aliquam ac risus quis leo semper viverra non ac nunc. Phasellus lacinia augue sed libero elementum, at interdum nunc posuere. Duis lacinia rhoncus urna eget scelerisque. Morbi ullamcorper tempus bibendum. Proin at est eget nibh dignissim bibendum. Fusce imperdiet ut urna nec mattis. Aliquam massa mauris, consequat tristique magna non, sodales tempus massa. Ut lobortis risus rhoncus, molestie mi vitae, accumsan enim. Quisque dapibus libero elementum lectus dignissim, non finibus lacus lacinia.
        </p><p>
        </body>
        </html>";
    }

    private string GetText_With_20_Tags()
    {
           return @"<html>
        <body>
        Lorem ipsum dolor sit [foo], consectetur [bar] elit. Proin nulla [convallis], faucibus a [vehicula] quis, posuere commodo elit. Nunc at tincidunt elit. Sed ipsum ex, accumsan sed viverra sit amet, tincidunt id nibh. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia curae; Nam interdum ex eget blandit lacinia. Nullam a tortor id sapien fringilla pellentesque vel ac purus. Fusce placerat dapibus tortor id luctus. Aenean in lacinia neque. Fusce quis ultrices odio. Nam id leo neque.

Etiam erat lorem, tincidunt [posuere] odio at, finibus pharetra felis. Sed magna enim, [z] at convallis a, [enim] eu quam. Vestibulum faucibus tincidunt ipsum et lacinia. Sed cursus ut arcu a commodo. Integer euismod eros at efficitur sollicitudin. In quis magna non orci sollicitudin condimentum. Fusce sed lacinia lorem, nec varius erat. In quis odio viverra, pharetra ex ac, hendrerit ante. Mauris congue enim et tellus sollicitudin pulvinar non sit amet tortor. Suspendisse at ex pharetra, semper diam ut, molestie velit. Cras lacinia urna neque, sit amet laoreet ex venenatis nec. Mauris at leo massa.

[suspendisse] mollis [amet] mi, sit amet venenatis enim rhoncus nec. Integer sit amet [y] tempor, finibus nisl quis, sodales ante. Curabitur suscipit dolor a dignissim consequat. Nulla eget vestibulum massa. Nam fermentum congue velit a placerat. Vivamus bibendum ex velit, id auctor ipsum bibendum eu. Praesent id gravida dui. Curabitur sollicitudin lobortis purus ac tempor. Sed felis enim, ornare et est egestas, blandit tincidunt lacus. Ut commodo dignissim augue, eget bibendum augue facilisis non.

Ut tortor neque, dignissim sit amet [lorem] ut, [ipsum] sit amet quam. [x] et leo ut est congue [new] et accumsan [ligula]. Aliquam erat dolor, eleifend a ipsum et, maximus suscipit ipsum. Nunc nec diam ex. Praesent suscipit aliquet condimentum. Nulla sodales lobortis fermentum. Maecenas ut laoreet sem. Ut id pulvinar urna, vel gravida lacus. Integer nunc urna, euismod eget vulputate sit amet, pharetra nec velit. Donec vel elit ac dolor varius faucibus tempus sed tortor. Donec metus diam, condimentum sit amet odio at, cursus cursus risus. Interdum et malesuada fames ac ante ipsum primis in faucibus. Nullam maximus tellus id quam consequat vestibulum. Curabitur rutrum eros tellus, eget commodo mauris sollicitudin a. In dignissim non est at pretium. Nunc bibendum pharetra dui ac ullamcorper.

Sed rutrum vehicula [accumsan]. Morbi eu [suscipit] [sit]. Aliquam vel [old] at felis [yada] dictum ac a justo. Suspendisse ultricies nisi turpis, non sagittis magna porttitor venenatis. Aliquam ac risus quis leo semper viverra non ac nunc. Phasellus lacinia augue sed libero elementum, at interdum nunc posuere. Duis lacinia rhoncus urna eget scelerisque. Morbi ullamcorper tempus bibendum. Proin at est eget nibh dignissim bibendum. Fusce imperdiet ut urna nec mattis. Aliquam massa mauris, consequat tristique magna non, sodales tempus massa. Ut lobortis risus rhoncus, molestie mi vitae, accumsan enim. Quisque dapibus libero elementum lectus dignissim, non finibus lacus lacinia.
        </p><p>
        </body>
        </html>";
    }

    private string GetText(int numberOfReplace)
    {
        if (numberOfReplace == 3)
            return GetText_With_3_Tags();
        if (numberOfReplace == 10)
            return GetText_With_10_Tags();
        if (numberOfReplace == 20)
            return GetText_With_20_Tags();

        return "";
    }

    public String_Replace()
    {
        _regexCompiled = new Regex(@"\[([^]]*)\]",RegexOptions.Compiled);
    }

    [Params(3,10,20)]
    public int ItemsToReplace { get; set; }

    [Benchmark]
    public void StringReplace()
    {
        var str = GetText(ItemsToReplace);
        foreach (var rep  in _valuesToReplace.Take(ItemsToReplace))
        {
            str = str.Replace("[" + rep.Key + "]", rep.Value);
        }
    }

    [Benchmark]
    public void StringBuilderReplace()
    {
        var sb = new StringBuilder(GetText(ItemsToReplace));
        foreach (var rep  in _valuesToReplace.Take(ItemsToReplace))
        {
            sb.Replace("[" + rep.Key + "]", rep.Value);
        }
        var res = sb.ToString();
    }

    [Benchmark]
    public void RegExReplace()
    {
        var str = GetText(ItemsToReplace);
        Regex regex = new Regex(@"\[([^]]*)\]");
        
        str = regex.Replace(str, Replace);
        var res = str;
    }

    

    [Benchmark]
    public void RegExReplace_Compiled()
    {
        var str = GetText(ItemsToReplace);

        str = _regexCompiled.Replace(str, Replace);
        var res = str;
    }

    private string Replace(Match match)
    {
        if(match.Groups.Count > 0)
        { 
            string collectionKey = match.Groups[1].Value;

            return _valuesToReplace[collectionKey];
        }
        return string.Empty;
    }

}

Answer 4

If you want to be really fast, and I mean really fast you'll have to look beyond the StringBuilder and just write well optimized code.

One thing your computer doesn't like to do is branching, if you can write a replace method which operates on a fixed array (char *) and doesn't branch you have great performance.

What you'll be doing is that the replace operation is going to search for a sequence of characters and if it finds any such sub string it will replace it. In effect you'll copy the string and when doing so, preform the find and replace.

You'll rely on these functions for picking the index of some buffer to read/write. The goal is to preform the replace method such that when nothing has to change you write junk instead of branching.

You should be able to complete this without a single if statement and remember to use unsafe code. Otherwise you'll be paying for index checking for every element access.

unsafe
{
    fixed( char * p = myStringBuffer )
    {
        // Do fancy string manipulation here
    }
}

I've written code like this in C# for fun and seen significant performance improvements, almost 300% speed up for find and replace. While the .NET BCL (base class library) performs quite well it is riddled with branching constructs and exception handling this will slow down you code if you use the built-in stuff. Also these optimizations while perfectly sound are not preformed by the JIT-compiler and you'll have to run the code as a release build without any debugger attached to be able to observe the massive performance gain.

I could provide you with more complete code but it is a substantial amount of work. However, I can guarantee you that it will be faster than anything else suggested so far.