Why is i = v[i++] undefined?

Question

From the C++ (C++11) standard, §1.9.15 which discusses ordering of evaluation, is the following code example:

void g(int i, int* v) {
    i = v[i++]; // the beha         


        

Answer 1

I would share your arguments if the example were v[++i], but since i++ modifies i as a side-effect, it is undefined as to when the value is modified. The standard could probably mandate a result one way or the other, but there's no true way of knowing what the value of i should be: (i + 1) or (v[i + 1]).