Can an INSERT operation result in a deadlock?

前端 未结 3 570
说谎
说谎 2021-02-01 04:43

Assuming:

  • I am using REPEATABLE_READ or SERIALIZABLE transaction isolation (locks get retained every time I access a row)
  • We are talking about multiple th
3条回答
  •  孤独总比滥情好
    2021-02-01 05:46

    Generally all modifications can cause a deadlock and selects will not (get to that later). So

    1. No you cannot ignore these.
    2. You can somewhat ignore select depending on your database and settings but the others will give you deadlocks.

    You don't even need multiple tables.

    The best way to create a deadlock is to do the same thing in a different order.

    SQL Server examples:

    create table A
    (
        PK int primary key
    )
    

    Session 1:

    begin transaction
    insert into A values(1)
    

    Session 2:

    begin transaction    
    insert into A values(7)
    

    Session 1:

    delete from A where PK=7
    

    Session 2:

    delete from A where PK=1
    

    You will get a deadlock. So that proved inserts & deletes can deadlock.

    Updates are similar:

    Session 1:

    begin transaction    
    insert into A values(1)
    insert into A values(2)
    commit
    
    begin transaction
    update A set PK=7 where PK=1
    

    Session 2:

    begin transaction
    update A set pk=9 where pk=2    
    update A set pk=8 where pk=1
    

    Session 1:

    update A set pk=9 where pk=2
    

    Deadlock!

    SELECT should never deadlock but on some databases it will because the locks it uses interfere with consistent reads. That's just crappy database engine design though.

    SQL Server will not lock on a SELECT if you use SNAPSHOT ISOLATION. Oracle & I think Postgres will never lock on SELECT (unless you have FOR UPDATE which is clearly reserving for an update anyway).

    So basically I think you have a few incorrect assumptions. I think I've proved:

    1. Updates can cause deadlocks
    2. Deletes can cause deadlocks
    3. Inserts can cause deadlocks
    4. You do not need more than one table
    5. You do need more than one session

    You'll just have to take my word on SELECT ;) but it will depend on your DB and settings.

提交回复
热议问题