I\'ve been looking at using the Excel VLOOKUP function to accomplish this, but I\'m pretty unfamiliar with it.
I need to do the following:
On sheet one, column A
You can enter in Sheet1!C1
=INDEX(Sheet2!C:C,SUMPRODUCT(--(Sheet2!A:A=A1),--(Sheet2!B:B=B1),ROW(Sheet2!C:C)),0)
and then copy downwards.
This does not require:
The importance of this is out of scope here.
What you are looking for is typically called Multiple Lookup. There are quite a few questions about it in SO, and many other articles elsewhere. I have compiled here a list of such posts.
There are many possible solutions for that. The one I found most robust is shown here. This is what I used in the present answer.