sql trigger to stop duplicates across row

Question

I have a table with multiple records:

• User_Name ( e.g. \'TOM\')
• Question_ID (eg \'q002\')
• Answer (e.g. \'D\')

i

Answer 1

MySql does not support INSTEAD OF triggers, which is what you'd need to use here. In SQL Server, you'd use an INSTEAD OF INSERT trigger that will fire before the insert occurs, where you can write a check for the duplicate. However, if you can avoid a trigger, why not use a Stored Routine and just check for the duplicate before inserting?

This is, of course, if you really, really cannot use a constraint.

Edit: Updating answer for MSSQL.

Here's an example right from MSDN:

CREATE TRIGGER IO_Trig_INS_Employee ON Employee
INSTEAD OF INSERT
AS
BEGIN
SET NOCOUNT ON
-- Check for duplicate Person. If there is no duplicate, do an insert.
IF (NOT EXISTS (SELECT P.SSN
      FROM Person P, inserted I
      WHERE P.SSN = I.SSN))
   INSERT INTO Person
      SELECT SSN,Name,Address,Birthdate
      FROM inserted
ELSE
-- Log an attempt to insert duplicate Person row in PersonDuplicates table.
   INSERT INTO PersonDuplicates
      SELECT SSN,Name,Address,Birthdate,SUSER_SNAME(),GETDATE()
      FROM inserted
-- Check for duplicate Employee. If no there is duplicate, do an INSERT.
IF (NOT EXISTS (SELECT E.SSN
      FROM EmployeeTable E, inserted
      WHERE E.SSN = inserted.SSN))
   INSERT INTO EmployeeTable
      SELECT EmployeeID,SSN, Department, Salary
      FROM inserted
ELSE
--If there is a duplicate, change to UPDATE so that there will not
--be a duplicate key violation error.
   UPDATE EmployeeTable
      SET EmployeeID = I.EmployeeID,
          Department = I.Department,
          Salary = I.Salary
   FROM EmployeeTable E, inserted I
   WHERE E.SSN = I.SSN
END

You'll obviously need to modify/simplify for your situation, but the basic context is there.