swift subclasses used in generics don't get called when inheriting from NSObject

Question

Partial Solution Update at the end!

Attached is code that produces odd behavior. I copied it out of a swift playground so it should run in one fine.

Answer 1

I was able to confirm your results and submitted it as a bug, https://bugs.swift.org/browse/SR-10617. Turns out this is a known issue! I was informed (by good old Hamish) that I was duplicating https://bugs.swift.org/browse/SR-10285.

In my bug submission, I created a clean compact reduction of your example, suitable for sending to Apple:

protocol P {
    init()
    func doThing()
}

class Wrapper {
    func go() {
        T().doThing()
    }
}

class A : NSObject, P {
    required override init() {}
    func doThing() {
        print("A")
    }
}

class B : A {
    required override init() {}
    override func doThing() {
        print("B")
    }
}

Wrapper().go()

On Xcode 9.2, we get "B". On Xcode 10.2, we get "A". That alone is enough to warrant a bug report.

In my report I listed three ways to work around the issue, all of which confirm that this is a bug (because none of them should make any difference):

• make the generic parameterized type's constraint be A instead of P

• or, mark the protocol P as @objc

• or, don't have A inherit from NSObject

---

UPDATE: And it turns out (from Apple's own release notes) there's yet another way:

• mark A's init as @nonobjc