Vectorized groupby with NumPy

Question

Pandas has a widely-used groupby facility to split up a DataFrame based on a corresponding mapping, from which you can apply a calculation on each subgroup and recombine the

Answer 1

How about using scipy sparse matrix

import numpy as np
from scipy import sparse
import time

x_len = 500000
g_len = 100

X = np.arange(x_len * 2).reshape(x_len, 2)
groups = np.random.randint(0, g_len, x_len)

# original
s = time.time()

a = np.array([X[groups==i].sum() for i in np.unique(groups)])

print(time.time() - s)

# using scipy sparse matrix
s = time.time()

x_sum = X.sum(axis=1)
b = np.array(sparse.coo_matrix(
    (
        x_sum,
        (groups, np.arange(len(x_sum)))
    ),
    shape=(g_len, x_len)
).sum(axis=1)).ravel()

print(time.time() - s)

#compare
print(np.abs((a-b)).sum())

result on my PC

0.15915322303771973
0.012875080108642578
0

More than 10 times faster.

---

Update!

Let's benchmark answers of @Paul Panzer and @Daniel F. It is summation only benchmark.

import numpy as np
from scipy import sparse
import time

# by @Daniel F
def groupby_np(X, groups, axis = 0, uf = np.add, out = None, minlength = 0, identity = None):
    if minlength < groups.max() + 1:
        minlength = groups.max() + 1
    if identity is None:
        identity = uf.identity
    i = list(range(X.ndim))
    del i[axis]
    i = tuple(i)
    n = out is None
    if n:
        if identity is None:  # fallback to loops over 0-index for identity
            assert np.all(np.in1d(np.arange(minlength), groups)), "No valid identity for unassinged groups"
            s = [slice(None)] * X.ndim
            for i_ in i:
                s[i_] = 0
            out = np.array([uf.reduce(X[tuple(s)][groups == i]) for i in range(minlength)])
        else:
            out = np.full((minlength,), identity, dtype = X.dtype)
    uf.at(out, groups, uf.reduce(X, i))
    if n:
        return out

x_len = 500000
g_len = 200

X = np.arange(x_len * 2).reshape(x_len, 2)
groups = np.random.randint(0, g_len, x_len)

print("original")
s = time.time()

a = np.array([X[groups==i].sum() for i in np.unique(groups)])

print(time.time() - s)

print("use scipy coo matrix")
s = time.time()

x_sum = X.sum(axis=1)
b = np.array(sparse.coo_matrix(
    (
        x_sum,
        (groups, np.arange(len(x_sum)))
    ),
    shape=(g_len, x_len)
).sum(axis=1)).ravel()

print(time.time() - s)

#compare
print(np.abs((a-b)).sum())


print("use scipy csr matrix @Daniel F")
s = time.time()
x_sum = X.sum(axis=1)
c = np.array(sparse.csr_matrix(
    (
        x_sum,
        groups,
        np.arange(len(groups)+1)
    ),
    shape=(len(groups), g_len)
).sum(axis=0)).ravel()

print(time.time() - s)

#compare
print(np.abs((a-c)).sum())


print("use bincount @Paul Panzer @Daniel F")
s = time.time()
d = np.bincount(groups, X.sum(axis=1), g_len)
print(time.time() - s)

#compare
print(np.abs((a-d)).sum())

print("use ufunc @Daniel F")
s = time.time()
e = groupby_np(X, groups)
print(time.time() - s)

#compare
print(np.abs((a-e)).sum())

STDOUT

original
0.2882847785949707
use scipy coo matrix
0.012301445007324219
0
use scipy csr matrix @Daniel F
0.01046299934387207
0
use bincount @Paul Panzer @Daniel F
0.007468223571777344
0.0
use ufunc @Daniel F
0.04431319236755371
0

The winner is the bincount solution. But the csr matrix solution is also very interesting.