Embedding Python on Windows: why does it have to be a DLL?

Question

I\'m trying to write a software plug-in that embeds Python. On Windows the plug-in is technically a DLL (this may be relevant). The Python Windows FAQ says:

Answer 1

(Sorry, I did a stupid thing, I first wrote the question, and then registered, and now I cannot alter it or comment on the replies, because StackOverflow's engine doesn't think I'm the author. I cannot even properly thank those who replied :( So this is actually an update to the question and comments.)

Thanks for all the advice, it's very valuable. As far as I understand with some effort I can link Python statically into a custom DLL, provided that I compile other dynamically loaded extensions myself and link them against the same DLL. (I know I need to ship the standard library too; my plan was to append a zipped archive to the DLL file. As far as I understand, I will even be able to import pure Python modules from it.)

I also found an interesting place in dynload_win.c. (I understand it loads dynamic extensions that use Python C API, e.g. _ctypes.) As far as I can see it not only looks for init_ctypes symbol or whatever the extension name is, but also scans the .pyd file's import table looking for (regex) python\d+\. and then compares the found symbol with known pythonNN. string to make sure the extension was compiled for this version of Python. If the import table doesn't have such a symbol or it refers to another version, it raises an error.

For me it means that:

• If I link an extension against pythonNN.dll and try to load it from my custom DLL that includes a statically linked Python, it will pass the check, but — well, here I'm not sure: will it fail because there's no pythonNN.dll (i.e. even before getting to the check) or it will happily load the symbols?
• And if I link it against my custom DLL, it will find symbols, but won't pass the check :)

I guess I could rewrite this piece to suit my needs... Are there any other such places, I wonder.