Better ways to implement a modulo operation (algorithm question)

Question

I\'ve been trying to implement a modular exponentiator recently. I\'m writing the code in VHDL, but I\'m looking for advice of a more algorithmic nature. The main componen

Answer 1

I'm not sure what you're calculating there to be honest. You talk about modulo operation, but usually a modulo operation is between two numbers a and b, and its result is the remainder of dividing a by b. Where is the a and b in your pseudocode...?

Anyway, maybe this'll help: a mod b = a - floor(a / b) * b.

I don't know if this is faster or not, it depends on whether or not you can do division and multiplication faster than a lot of subtractions.

Another way to speed up the subtraction approach is to use binary search. If you want a mod b, you need to subtract b from a until a is smaller than b. So basically you need to find k such that:

a - k*b < b, k is min

One way to find this k is a linear search:

k = 0;
while ( a - k*b >= b )
    ++k;

return a - k*b;

But you can also binary search it (only ran a few tests but it worked on all of them):

k = 0;
left = 0, right = a
while ( left < right )
{
    m = (left + right) / 2;
    if ( a - m*b >= b )
       left = m + 1;
    else
       right = m;
}

return a - left*b;

I'm guessing the binary search solution will be the fastest when dealing with big numbers.

If you want to calculate a mod b and only a is a big number (you can store b on a primitive data type), you can do it even faster:

for each digit p of a do
    mod = (mod * 10 + p) % b
return mod

This works because we can write a as a_n*10^n + a_(n-1)*10^(n-1) + ... + a_1*10^0 = (((a_n * 10 + a_(n-1)) * 10 + a_(n-2)) * 10 + ...

I think the binary search is what you're looking for though.