Unit testing private code [duplicate]

Answer 1

There is really only two cases you need to consider:

1. the private code is called, directly or indirectly from public code and
2. the private code is not called from public code.

In the first case, the private code is automatically being tested by the tests which exercise the public code that calls the private code, so there is no need to test the private code. And in the second case, the private code cannot be called at all, therefore it should be deleted, not tested.

Ergo: there is no need to explicitly test the private code.

Note that when you do TDD it is impossible for untested private code to even exist. Because when you do TDD, the only way that private code can be appear, is by an Extract {Method|Class|...} Refactoring from public code. And Refactorings are, by definition, behavior-preserving and therefore test-coverage-preserving. And the only way that public code can appear is as the result of a failing test. If public code can only appear as already tested code as the result of a failing test, and private code can only appear as the result of being extracted from public code via a behavior-preserving refactoring, it follows that untested private code can never appear.