Advantages of dynamic vs static routing in React

Question

I\'m reading about static vs dynamic routing in React Router, and I\'m struggling to identify the advantages of the latter (and why v4 chose to go with it). I can see the ad

Answer 1

Dynamic Routing

From the react router docs:

When we say dynamic routing, we mean routing that takes place as your app is rendering, not in a configuration or convention outside of a running app.

Think of routes as components

The earlier versions of react-router (pre v4) used to have static routes. This led to a centralized routing in apps like:

    
      
      
      
      ...
    

However, this is not exactly the React way of doing things. React focuses on composition using components based logic. So, instead of imagining our Routes as a static system, we can imagine them as components, which is what react-router v4 brings in and the primary philosophy behind it.

Therefore, we can use Route as we would use any React component. This lets us add Route components as and when we build different components. One advantage of doing this is we can decouple the routing logic to the components needing them.

Nesting routes

The About component can handle all the routes and conditionally render parts of UI based on the url (say /about/job or /about/life etc).

Another thing to note is that a Route component will either render the component for a matching route or null. Example, the following Route renders the About component for a route /about and null (or nothing) otherwise.

This is also similar to how we're used to conditionally rendering components in React:

route === '/about' ?  : null

Now if we need to render some other components inside the About component for routes /about/job or /about/life we can do it like:

const About = ({ match ) => (
    

        ...
        
        
    
)

Dynamic imports and code splitting

Personally, I've also found this approach works better for me in case I'm using dynamic imports with code-splitting, since I can add dynamic routes in any of my components. For example,

import Loadable from 'react-loadable';

const Loading = () => (
    

);

const Job = Loadable({
    loader: () => import('./Job'),
    loading: Loading,
});

const Life = Loadable({
    loader: () => import('./Life'),
    loading: Loading,
});

...

render() {
    return (
        ...
        
        
    )
}

Responsive routes

Another great use case for dynamic routing is creating responsive routes which is explained beautifully in the react router docs and a recommended read. Here's the example from the docs:

const App = () => (
  
    
  
)

const Invoices = () => (
  

    {/* always show the nav */}
    

    
      {screenIsSmall => screenIsSmall
        // small screen has no redirect
        ? 
            
            
          
        // large screen does!
        : 
            
            
            
          
      }
    
  
)

Summarizing the docs, you'll notice how simple and declarative it becomes to add the Redirect to large screen sizes using dynamic routing. Using static routing in such cases would be quite cumbersome and would need us to put all the routes in a single place. Having dynamic routing simplifies this problem since now the logic becomes composable (like components).

Static Routing

There are some problems which are not solved easily with dynamic routing. An advantage of static routing is that it allows for inspection and matching of routes before rendering. Hence it proves useful especially on server side. The react router team is also working on a solution called react-router-config, quoting from which:

With the introduction of React Router v4, there is no longer a centralized route configuration. There are some use-cases where it is valuable to know about all the app's potential routes such as:

1. Loading data on the server or in the lifecycle before rendering the next screen
2. Linking to routes by name
3. Static analysis

Hope this provides a good summary of both Dynamic Routing and Static Routing and the use cases for them :)