Test a specific exception type is thrown AND the exception has the right properties

Question

I want to test that MyException is thrown in a certain case. EXPECT_THROW is good here. But I also want to check the exception has a specific state

Answer 1

Jeff Langr describes a good approach in his book, Modern C++ Programming with Test-Driven Development:

If your [testing] framework does not support a single-line declarative assert that ensures an exception is thrown, you can use the following structure in your test:

    TEST(ATweet, RequiresUserNameToStartWithAnAtSign) {
        string invalidUser("notStartingWith@");
        try {
            Tweet tweet("msg", invalidUser);
            FAIL();
        }
        catch(const InvalidUserException& expected) {}
    }

[...] You might also need to use the try-catch structure if you must verify any postconditions after the exception is thrown. For example, you may want to verify the text associated with the thrown exception object.

    TEST(ATweet, RequiresUserNameToStartWithAtSign) {
        string invalidUser("notStartingWith@");
        try {
            Tweet tweet("msg", invalidUser);
            FAIL();
        }
        catch(const InvalidUserException& expected) {
            ASSERT_STREQ("notStartingWith@", expected.what());
        }
    }

(p.95)

This is the approach I've used, and have seen in practice elsewhere.

Edit: As has been pointed out by @MikeKinghan, this doesn't quite match the functionality provided by EXPECT_THROW; the test doesn't fail if the wrong exception is thrown. An additional catch clause could be added to address this:

catch(...) {
    FAIL();
}