Extending a struct in C

Question

I recently came across a colleague\'s code that looked like this:

typedef struct A {
  int x;
}A;

typedef struct B {
  A a;
  int d;
}B;

void fn(){
  B *b;         


        

Answer 1

I am sorry to disagree with all the other answers here, but this system is not compliant to standard C. It is not acceptable to have two pointers with different types which point to the same location at the same time, this is called aliasing and is not allowed by the strict aliasing rules in C99 and many other standards. A less ugly was of doing this would be to use in-line getter functions which then do not have to look neat in that way. Or perhaps this is the job for a union? Specifically allowed to hold one of several types, however there are a myriad of other drawbacks there too.

In short, this kind of dirty casting to create polymorphism is not allowed by most C standards, just because it seems to work on your compiler does not mean it is acceptable. See here for an explanation of why it is not allowed, and why compilers at high optimization levels can break code which does not follow these rules http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliasing_%28computing%29#Conflicts_with_optimization