I\'ve been trying very hard to get gitolite working. I used the package approach and am able to do a first \"git push\" with a first user to the server. After that, if if
I guess this is because I'm adding private keys for both users
True, you should use a dedicated public/private key for the gitolite user, the one which is also used for ssh access.
You can confirm it by looking in the gitolite logs (in ~gitolite/.gitolite/logs)
Using multiple keys is done through a config file.
See as an example "users are asked for password while using gitolite".
The %HOME%/.ssh/config file could contain something like:
HostName gitoliteserver
User gitolite
IdentityFile ~/.ssh/gitolite
Host mikegitolite
HostName gitoliteserver
User mike
IdentityFile ~/.ssh/id_rsa
Don't forget to define HOME is you are on Windows: it isn't defined by default)
The OP Mike Gagnon confirms in the comments the following config is working:
host gitolite
user gitolite
hostname myhost
port 443
IdentityFile ~/.ssh/gitolite
host edison
user gitolite
hostname myhost
port 443
IdentityFile ~/.ssh/mike