I have a legacy data table in SQL Server 2005 that has a PK with no identity/autoincrement and no power to implement one.
As a result, I am forced to create new rec
The best solution is to change the database. You may not be able to change the column to be an identity column, but you should be able to make sure there's a unique constraint on the column and add a new identity column seeded with your existing PK's. Then either use the new column instead or use a trigger to make the old column mirror the new, or both.