We have found that SQL Server is using an index scan instead of an index seek if the where clause contains parametrized values instead of string literal.
I guess first query is using predicate and second query is using seek predicate.
Seek Predicate is the operation that describes the b-tree portion of the Seek. Predicate is the operation that describes the additional filter using non-key columns. Based on the description, it is very clear that Seek Predicate is better than Predicate as it searches indexes whereas in Predicate, the search is on non-key columns – which implies that the search is on the data in page files itself.
For more details please visit:- https://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/sqlserver/en-US/36a176c8-005e-4a7d-afc2-68071f33987a/predicate-and-seek-predicate