Atomic Reference Counting

Question

I\'m trying to understand exactly how thread-safe, atomic reference counting works, for example as with std::shared_ptr. I mean, the basic concept is simple, b

Answer 1

You probably overestimate the threadsafety a shared_ptr provides.

The essence of atomic ref counting is to ensure that if two different instances of a shared_ptr (that are managing the same object) are accessed/modified, there will be no race condition. However, shared_ptr doesn't ensure thread safety, if two threads access the same shared_ptr object (and one of them is a write). One example would be e.g. if one thread dereferences the pointer, while the other resets it.
So about the only thing shared_ptr gurantees is that there will be no double delete and no leak as long as there is no race on a single instance of a shared_ptr (It also doesn't make accesses to the object it points to threadsafe)

As a result, also creating a copy of a shared_ptr is only safe, if there is no other thread that could delete/reset it at the same time (you could also say, it is not internally synchronized). This is the scenario you describe.

To repeat it once more: Accessing a single shared_ptr instance from multiple threads where one of those accesses is a write to the pointer is still a race condition.

If you want to e.g. copy a std::shared_ptrin a threadsafe manner, you have to ensure that all loads and stores happen via std::atomic_... operations which are specialized for shared_ptr.