How to pass LongRunning flag specifically to Task.Run()?

Question

I need a way to set an async task as long running without using Task.Factory.StartNew(...) and instead using Task.Run(...) or something similar.

Context:

I h

Answer 1

I think the consideration should be not how long the thread run but how much of its time is it really working. In your example there is short work and them await Task.Delay(...). If this is really the case in your project you probably shouldn't use a dedicated thread for this task and let it run on the regular thread pool. Every time you'll call await on an IO operation or on Task.Delay() you'll release the thread for other tasks to use.

You should only use LongRunning when you'll decrease your thread from the thread-pool and never give it back or give it back only for a small percentage of the time. In such a case (where the work is long and Task.Delay(...) is short in comparison) using a dedicated thread for the job is a reasonable solution. On the other hand if your thread is really working most of the time it will consume system resources (CPU time) and maybe it doesn't really matter if it holds a thread of the thread-pool since it is preventing other work from happening anyway.

Conclusion? Just use Task.Run() (without LongRunning) and use await in your long running task when and if it is possible. Revert to LongRunning only when you actually see the other approach is causing you problems and even then check your code and design to make sure it is really necessary and there isn't something else you can change in your code.