Docker named volumes vs DOC (data-only-containers)

Question

Up to recent version of Docker (v1.10), we were thought that we can use DOC: data-only containers. So I would create such DOC (based on e.g. busybox) and use

Answer 1

Can we replace DOC with named containers?

In many cases, yes, named containers will be a better option.

How long volume is persisted? What if I remove the container that is using it?

If you remove the container, the volume will still be there. The only way to remove the volume is to use docker-compose down -v or docker volume rm .

How can we e.g. backup now? Previously, I could docker run --rm --volumes-from es-data ... and then tar it.

Instead of --volumes-from, you can use --volume=.

Note that volumes created by docker-compose are always prefixed with the project name, so if you use it with a docker command the full name is actually _es-data.