Should css class names like 'floatleft' that directly describe the attached style be avoided?

Question

Lots of websites use class names like floatleft, clearfloat, alignright, small, center etc that describe the

Answer 1

From what I've seen, developers have the tendency to overload their HTML pages with way too many unnecessary classes and extra markup. These classes not only make the page size bigger (and thus the load time longer), they also crowd up the page and make it difficult to manage and modify at a later time.

Having things like center and float-left might be helpful when you're dealing with display text that was input by a user (such as a post on a forum), but for general markup purposes you're better off just adding text-align: center and float: left to the appropriate classes. This especially helps if you are trying to change the appearance of your site without changing the HTML much. The less you have hardcoded into your template, the easier it is to only have to change around the CSS when modifying your template. That bit alone is worth it to me.

As a general rule of thumb, you really should only give elements classes when it describes what the content is, not where or how it is being displayed. i.e. instead of .

The only time I feel that it makes sense to give an element a class when it isn't necessary is if you are concerned with Search Engine Optimization. You should definitely read up on Microformats if you are interested in seeing how adding the right classes can actually help search engines. That being said, adding classes that describe how the page is visually displayed does nothing for the search engines.

The only time I would ever "group" classes is if they are either displaying the same thing, or if they are siblings. It gets really messy in your CSS when you have elements from all over your page defined together. You're much better off grouping your classes in your stylesheet in ways that you will be able to find them later, rather than saving a few lines by combining them.