(Boolean. false) in Clojure

后端 未结 3 1444
隐瞒了意图╮
隐瞒了意图╮ 2020-12-11 17:11

According to http://hyperpolyglot.org/lisp, the only falsehoods in Clojure are false and nil. Indeed, surprisingly enough, (Boolean. false)

3条回答
  •  忘掉有多难
    2020-12-11 17:23

    You can find the explanation at http://clojure.org/special_forms#if.

    It's good to read the whole paragraph, but here's the crucial bit excerpted, emphasis added:

    [...] All [...] conditionals in Clojure are based upon the same logic, that is, nil and false constitute logical falsity, and everything else constitutes logical truth, and those meanings apply throughout. [...] Note that if does not test for arbitrary values of java.lang.Boolean, only the singular value false (Java's Boolean.FALSE), so if you are creating your own boxed Booleans make sure to use Boolean/valueOf and not the Boolean constructors.

    Compare

    System.out.println(Boolean.valueOf(false) ? true : false);  // false
    System.out.println(new Boolean(false)     ? true : false);  // false
    

    with

    user=> (if (Boolean/valueOf false) true false)
    false
    user=> (if (Boolean. false) true false)
    true
    

    Thus, (Boolean. false) is neither nil nor false, just as (Object.) is neither nil nor false. And as @Chiron has pointed out, it's bad practice to use it anyway.

    As for (= false (Boolean. false)) being true, I think @looby's explanation is spot on: Since = relies on Java's equals method, the special semantics of conditionals in Clojure don't apply, and boolean equality will be as it is in Java.

提交回复
热议问题