Issues with T-SQL TRY CATCH?

Question

We are currently on SQL 2005 at work and I am migrating an old Foxpro system to new web application backed by SQL Server. I am using TRY CATCH in T-SQL for transaction proce

Answer 1

I have never hit a situation where TRY...CATCH... failed. Neiteher, probably, have many of the people who read this question. This, alas, only means that if there is such a SQL bug, then we haven't seen it. The thing is, that's a pretty big "if". Believe it or not, Microsoft does put some effort into making their core software products pretty solid, and TRY...CATCH... is hardly a new concept. A quick example: In SQL 2005, I encountered a solid, demonstrable, and replicable bug while working out then-new table partitioning--which bug that had already been fixed by a patch. And TRY...CATCH... gets used a bit more frequently than table partitioning.

I'd say the burden of proof falls on your co-worker. If he "heard it somewhere", then he should try and back it up with some kind of evidence. The internet is full of proof for the old saying "just because everyone says its so, doesn't mean they're right".