For completeness, if you wanted to use replaceFirst, try this:
public static String cap1stChar(String userIdea)
{
String betterIdea = userIdea;
if (userIdea.length() > 0)
{
String first = userIdea.substring(0,1);
betterIdea = userIdea.replaceFirst(first, first.toUpperCase());
}
return betterIdea;
}//end cap1stChar